preview

Police Brutality

Decent Essays

Police brutality is an issue fraught with statistical misconceptions. The debate is often over whether police brutality incidents are either underreported or accurate. Despite the fact that numbers are used in both arguments, this does not serve as true empirical evidence since the numbers lack the proper context necessary to make assumptions from the statistics. For example, a statistic was produced by The Free Thought Project stating that “police in the United States kill 70 times the rate of other first world nations (Agorist 2015).” Additionally, the language surrounding the term “police brutality” is vague, making it difficult to identify what police brutality actually is. Ultimately, this causes police brutality to be underreported as …show more content…

The definition of brutality is subjective. Merriam-Webster defines police brutality as using “excessive force (Merriam-Webster 2017).” However, the word excessive is also a subjective adjective that has not been clearly defined by the law yet in the context of law enforcement. Police brutality does not define what types of brutality it refers to, which highlights another fallacy of the term police brutality. The definition of brutality alone could range from verbal harassment to wrongful death. This is not only problematic legally, but also statistically. If one cannot define what police brutality exactly is in plain language, it cannot be quantified into a statistic. As a result, the word police brutality needs to be defined more specifically in more empirical …show more content…

“If an officer intentionally fires a gun in Montgomery County, Maryland – even if no one is hit or hurt – the police department posts a detailed description of the circumstances on its home page, usually within 24 hours. It is policy. (McCarthy 2015).” In other places, the police do not report incidents of police brutality because transparency is not required in the department. It is not in the police department’s interest to publicize police brutality incidents.
Another cause for this false statistic is due to the variation in enforcement of existing data collection between police departments. Even if adequate standardized data collection policies exist, not all police departments enforce adhesion to these policies consistently. If police departments do not enforce the policies consistently, then many police brutality incidents will go unreported since there is a higher incentive for police officers to not report them. In turn, this inevitably distorts police brutality statistics that are provided to the

Get Access