preview

Persuasive Essay: Student Searches

Decent Essays

Student searches Student searches help schools prevent distribution and usage of drugs, and weapons, but do they infringe on our constitutional rights? Yes, they do. Student searches take away the student`s right to privacy, their right to not be unreasonably searched, and they take up time and resources that some schools don’t have. Student searches are a tactic used by schools around the country and by every school that has ever existed even though they are unconstitutional. Schools have been violating student’s right to privacy for decades, but it’s ok because it is in the name of greater safety. In the case of New Jersey v. T.L.O. “The Court concluded that searches by school officials are governed …show more content…

The fourth amendment states that it is “The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated…” and so when you go to school you have your person, papers, and effects. If you are searched at school without a warrant, then the school district is actively violating your right to not be unreasonably searched. Schools often take their searches to far as seen the Safford Unified School District v. Redding case. It was also said that “It does not take a constitutional scholar to conclude that a nude search of a 13-year-old girl is an invasion of constitutional rights. More than that: it is a violation of any known principle of human dignity.” (Judge Tom, 2016). Students falsely reporting prohibited substances which result in unreasonable searches. Unfortunately a ruling in the T.L.O. case which “…held that students remain free from unreasonable searches and seizures.”(Butterfield, 1995) did not stop the Redding girl from being striped searched.it is quite frankly sad that our schools feel the need to unreasonably search students all the while taking up time and resources that some schools just don’t …show more content…

(Analysis of School Shootings, 2015) and even if half of the 56% had been caught by random student searches which probably wouldn’t happen anyway it still probably would fix the situation only escalate it. And others may say that student searches keep a safe and drug free environment to “…help preserve and foster a safe, non-disruptive educational environment for effective teaching and learning...” (STUDENT SEARCH AND SEIZURE 2004) but, kids are going to buy and sell weed and other drugs whether at their school or not. And not very many people are stupid enough to show up to school high. Also kids aren’t going to get high at school so they don’t bring their drug unless their selling it. And then if they are selling it their probably not going to keep it on their person or in their

Get Access