preview

Patterns In Ann Jane Thornton's Literature

Decent Essays
Open Document

The persona of Ann Jane Thornton, though influenced by the narrative of ‘lost love’ used in female sailor stories past, was largely shaped by the expectations of feminine weakness that gained prominence in the 1830s. The character that was developed, though exhibiting bravery and determination believed to be unusual for a female, was consistently placed in a subordinate position to male members of the supporting cast. Additionally, placing emphasis on the redeeming nature of her love story limited the implications tied to a female actually succeeding in typical male behavior. These efforts to feminize Thornton, even as she was disguised in male garb, reflected Craft-Fairchild’s argument that female cross dressers in the early nineteenth century were increasingly domesticated and delicate, as some became uneasy at their ‘sexual and social ambiguity’. …show more content…

While Dugaw’s work addressed female cross dressers over a two hundred year period, this narrow focus on the specific social and gender influences of a very limited time period provided beneficial insight into fluctuations the trope encountered. Furthermore, addressing this later time period that was often overlooked in the historiography of female sailors opens avenues of discussion for the rest of the nineteenth century as well. A news article printed in The Examiner on March 25, 1843 clearly indicates a basis for an inquiry into the decade following Thornton stating that:
Two or three years ago there was a great run on female sailors. Every newspaper has its paragraph announcing the discovery of a female sailor. The result was a thorough conviction in the public mind that all sailors were female sailors- that there were no other sailors than female sailors in

Get Access