preview

Outline the View That Big Supermarkets Both Provide and Limit Choice

Good Essays

Outline the view that big supermarkets both provide and limit choice. In the context of our consumer society, the role of big supermarkets and their influence on our lives has come under much scrutiny. Broadly split into an anti-supermarket and pro-supermarket camp, both sides insist that their interpretation of evidence is the correct one, and that their conclusions are sound. In light of such contention, I will explore both sides of the argument, and attempt to explain how an answer can be both ‘yes’ and ‘no’ , depending on which perspective you are looking from, and how you interpret the evidence used to support it. That the big supermarkets (in particular the ‘big four’; Tesco, Asda, Sainsbury’s, Morrison’s) have power, is not in …show more content…

Are we in the UK now all seduced by the prices lowered as a consequence of third-world repression? Or on a national level, are a number of us being seduced into becoming the repressed, as public spending dwindles despite increasing needs? Because Galbraith also believed of consumer societies that “This exuberance in private production and consumption pushes out public spending and investment” (Galbraith, J.K 1958) The complexity of the issue becomes clear as each successive claim can be shown to be dependent on exactly how you choose to interpret the terms we use to describe it. From a global outlook, both sides in the supermarket debate again adopt a stance based on the founding assumption of zero sum or positive sum game. Supermarket proponents claim that they are creating jobs in countries where there were none, and contributing to the global economy by paying workers in these countries a living wage. Opponents counter claim that supermarkets are abusing their power to pay wages far below what can be described as a living wage, and that the real cost of the low prices in our supermarkets is borne by these workers, often women and children, who work long hours in garment factories or sweatshops in countries where laws regarding pay and conditions for workers are far less stringent than in Europe or the U.S. In her book ‘No Logo, Naomi Klein quotes from a letter written to Disney CEO Michael Eisner by

Get Access