preview

Noongar Aboriginal People Summary

Decent Essays

A holistic and contextual understanding of indigenous communities in Australia alters the nature of research and the perception of history. Clint Bracknell’s article critiques historical research on the arts of Noongar Aboriginal peoples, and argues how song is not only an integral part of their identity but that it is through the insight of this form of communication that researchers comprehend how Noongar have adopted Western traditions but still remained close to their heritage. As a descendant from Noongar, situated in south-west of Australia, he is closely attached to this research, so it is understandable why his purpose is to encourage investigation into the archival records of song from Noongar peoples as to revitalise an indigenous …show more content…

By only observing and analysing other people’s theories, he deduces his own logical interpretation. An example of this is that he finds a false representation from White’s perception of Noongar’s encounter with the performance of a British military drill. Using Grey’s and Swan’s opposing ideas, he argues this to be simple-minded and an uneducated viewpoint. Albeit, he does feel that the British had good intentions as to integrate with an indigenous group. Amusingly, a colonialist viewpoint can be drawn from this as it could be a tool for the British to feel significant about themselves while they are chasing to conquer the globe, however that would cause conflicts with the idea of discourses and unsupported claims. In essence, he restricts himself to using archival evidence to support his claim, and not his previous knowledge as a Noongar descendant. With this, he inadvertently challenges himself to justify his own statement that “an understanding of Noongar language and song… have the capacity to divine more evidentiary data from the archives.” Though, he does resort to Clendinnen to point out how Aboriginal history being shared aurally, makes it harder for non-aboriginals to comprehend it. However, the statement still gives his claims weight as through evidence, his promises are fulfilled, which is an optimistic outlook for the aspiring researchers.
All things considered,

Get Access