preview

Neuroscience Research Paper

Good Essays

Neuroscience: The Risks of Reading the Brain
Poldrack, Russell. "Neuroscience: The Risks of Reading the Brain." Nature News.
Nature Publishing Group, 11 Jan. 2017.

Seymour James D. Barrion
Research-Based Article Critique Report
06 May 2017 Abstract
It is widely known that the brain perceives information before it reaches the consciousness of a person. But until now, there was little way to determine what specific mental tasks were taking place prior to the point of conscious awareness. That changed with the findings of scientists at Rutgers University in Newark and the University of California, Los Angeles have developed a highly accurate way to peer into the brain to uncover the mental state of a person and what kind of information …show more content…

The problem was clearly stated and is practically important to the purpose of the study. Their big goal is to use fMRI-based lie detection and be admitted as evidence in court. However, this machine is not 100% accurate. It will only show us light that will tell us that the people are lying based on their memory. Moreover, one particularly problematic topic is one of the false memories. The scans can only reflect your beliefs, not necessarily reality. If you disbelieve that you have committed a crime, fMRI can only confirm this belief. We may be convinced to see brain scans of hard evidence, but they are only as good as your own memories: ultimately imperfect.

Review and Literature

The cited sources are pertinent to the study. The analysis was too broad because it talks about the mind and how machines are able to read it. It also talked about how accurate and inaccurate the machine is. Nevertheless, there was no cited evidence of bias. The words were correctly used and can easily be defined.

Design and …show more content…

It can be used in commercial settings without appropriate guidelines. Academic researchers need to go through a thorough process to start an fMRI study. This process will explain potential risks and benefits of an ethics committee. No such rules exist in the commercial setting. Companies are free to buy an fMRI scanner and perform experiments in any design. They can show you traumatizing scene or they may uncover the thoughts that you want to keep to yourself. They are not forced to tell you about the medical abnormalities if your scan shows

Get Access