preview

NFL Team Name Analysis

Decent Essays

In recent discussions of the name and logo of the NFL Team the Washington Redskins, a controversial issue has been whether the name is truly offensive to Native American communities. On one hand, the team itself argued that the name originated from a place of honor and respect for Native Americans (Washington Redskins response statement). From this perspective, the name is not offensive but in fact goes to support Native American communities. In May of 2013, The team’s president Bruce Allen said in response to a letter from congress that the team’s name and logo not only has the support of Native American people, but that the team is a positive and needed influence. In October of 2013, team Owner Dan Snyder called the name a “badge of honor” …show more content…

On the other hand, however, others argue that the name is extremely offensive and derogatory. In the words of Bruce Anderson, both a former player for the team and a member of the Coquille Tribe, “I ask Snyder to consider how the name affects my children and my grandchildren. How they struggle with their identities. How they must constantly fight to resuscitate and continue their traditions as a people. How they have to do this while dealing with classmates, friends and teachers whose only understanding of them may be drawn from the stereotypes of “Indians” depicted by some sports fans” (“Washington NFL Team’s Name Only Preserves Native American Stereotypes,” The Washington Post). According to this view, the name only serves to …show more content…

Though I concede that the original naming of the team may have been intended to be a gesture of respect and honor, I maintain that the name has become derogatory term that is discouraging for many Native Americans. Shown by the American Psychological Association, when in August of 2005 it adopted a resolution calling for the abandonment of all Native American mascots. The APA cited studies showing that these mascots and team names deny Native Americans societal definitions of themselves, create a racially hostile environment, and have a negative impact on the self esteem of Native American children (“APA Resolution Calling for the Immediate Retirement of Native-Themed Mascots,” American Psychological Association.) Although some might object, such as Snyder in his aforementioned letter to fans, that there are many Americans who do not want the name to change and even some in Native American communities who are not offended by the name. I would reply that that is irrelevant. No one gets to decide what is offensive to Native American peoples except for Native Americans themselves, and no single Native American speaks for the thoughts and opinions of so many diverse communities. This issue is of vital importance because it affects the lives, development, and identities of many Native Americans, which should always be prioritized over the preferences or traditions of an

Get Access