preview

Maquiladoras And NAFTA

Good Essays

NAFTA and Maquiladoras

The North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA), which became effective on January 1, 1994, is a comprehensive, rules-based agreement designed to promote “free-trade” among the United States, Mexico and Canada (NAFTA Forum,1998). Although the agreement was made between three countries, it was largely the inclusion of Mexico around which most of the oppositional debate was centered (Mayer, 1998). Canada is a modern, developed nation very similar in culture and economy to the United States. Mexico, however, is considered a developing nation with an economy much weaker than the United States. Still, a prior trade agreement did exist between the United States and Mexico. Therefore, in order to properly evaluate …show more content…

In 1989, the AFL-CIO produced a film about toxic dumping at a Mexican maquiladora, and even worked with ABC’s “20/20” program and NBC’s “Dateline” on stories about toxic hazards in Mexican maquiladoras. In 1989, the AFL-CIO joined environmental and citizen rights groups such as The Border Ecology Project and the Quaker American Friends Service Committee in forming the Coalition for Justice in the Maquiladoras. Environmental and human rights abuses were a means for the American public to focus on the loss of American jobs. As one AFL-CIO official stated, regarding the American public, “Nobody cared about a worker losing his job in Illinois. They were much more sensitive to toxic dumping in Mexico” (Mayer, 1998). Environmental opponents saw the Maquiladora Program as being extremely harmful to the environment, and publicized instances of American companies attempting to take advantage of Mexico’s poor environmental record. Once NAFTA became an important political objective, labor and environmental groups found an opportunity to promote their own particular objectives. As a result, NAFTA would not be passed unless the labor and environmental opponents were appeased, and it is from there that the two side agreements were born.

NAFTA should not be evaluated separately from previous trade agreements between the United States and Mexico. The

Get Access