Myths in the Criminal Justice system have plagued the public for years, and can be detrimental, even on a State level. In New York State, the myth that the state is more dangerous than it has ever been can lead to other myths being believed which can turn into poor policy such as the “get tough” approach. By comparing New York State data to data from Canada, the effectiveness of this myth can be debunked and disproven.
In order to discuss the myths surrounding violent crime in New York State, understanding the current data and trends is essential. To establish the general consensus of what people think about violent crime in New York State, I conducted a small poll of people in my area. In essence, the aim was to see whether or not
…show more content…
Due to the conflicting approaches between NYS and Canada on handling crime, I felt Canada was a good choice for this comparison. Canada in 1975 showed an even lower crime rate than NYS (see figure 1) but also peaked around the same years that NYS did (See figure 2 and 3 for visual comparison), with Canada’s highest violent crime rate in the range of dates falling in 1993 at 1082. Canada’s last data year was 2013, with a crime rate of 766. At first glance, the drop doesn’t seem as strong as the one NYS made, however, this is a significant decrease from years before, with the drop between 2012-2013 at 75. In NYS, the drop between 2013-2014 was only 12 (See figure 1). Additionally, the violent crime rate for NYS seems to be leveling out (see figure 2), whereas the violent crime rate for Canada appears to be starting to drop significantly (see figure 3). Overall, however, violent crime rates have dropped significantly for both areas since the 1990s, the peak rate of crime for both areas in this range of dates.
With this in mind, Canada and NYS are diversely different in their approach to crime. Knowing that both areas have experienced a drop in crime rate, it can be concluded that both areas are safe. Nevertheless, the areas didn’t reach these drops the same way. New York State is known for its “get tough” approach to crime, while Canada is known for
In the second part of Parenti’s book, Lockdown America, he discusses policing practices and their proactive strategies aimed at preventing disorder. In this section of the book, Parenti advances his argument by looking at crime through the eyes of law enforcement. Parenti looks at the policies of Bratton, the New York Police Commissioner. Bratton revamped the police force in the city, rewarded those that succeeded and were aggressive in doing their job and those that did not keep up with him were fired or put on the sidelines. His goals was to be efficient on every level, and being efficient meant enforcing the law even for minor offences.
In New York City, many attribute the drop in crime rates to the institution of Broken Windows Policing (BWP) in ’93. Oddly the drop began before this policy was instituted and was also mirrored across the United States. Drum presents the theory
As mentioned, Canada is utilizing an alternative response to crime that is not primarily based in mass incarceration and punishments(Webster, C., & Doob, A, 2008). This result was possible in Canada because Canada has managed to resist wider punitive trends in terms of crime control against crimes. I believe Canada’s stability in levels of incarceration over the last 40 years is rooted in Canada’s cultural beliefs on restraint in the use of imprisonment and punishment itself
Throughout crime in Australia, a noticeable increase in crime occurred between the 1970’s to the 1990’s but has declined to a stable rate of crime which is similar trend in America. However, crime itself is often complex to define due to the variety of crime. Therefore, it is difficult to accurately measure crime and if crime cannot be measured efficiently and it proposes concerns of whether crime in Australia is stable or not. Although Australia’s system of collecting crime data is striving to be as accurate as possible, the media will often manipulate the data which misleads the Australian public of crime stability. Inclusively, through gaining an understanding of defining crime, accurately measuring data and comparing Australia’s crime data
According to the 2015 and 2016 Uniform Crime Reporting Survey, the overall Canadian Crime rates appear to be gradually increasing, as of 2016 (Allen, 2016; Keighley, 2017). In 2015, the police-reported crime rate in Canada raised for the first time since 2003, with the volume of police-reported crime increased for 3% from 2014 to 2015 (the crime rate
In chapter 4 the chapter considers a variety of possible explanations for the significant drop in crime and crime rates that occurred in the 1990s. Based on articles that appeared in the country’s largest newspapers, the authors compile a list of the leading, commonly offered explanations. The next step is to systematically examine each explanation and consider whether available data support the explanation. What the authors, in fact, demonstrate is that in all but three cases–increased reliance on prisons, increased number of police, and changes in illegal drug markets–correlation was erroneously interpreted as causation and in some cases, the correlation wasn’t even that strong.
Since crime was first measured in Canada, fluctuations have been noticed in the crime rate from year-to-year. According to Statistics Canada, from 1962 to 1991, the police-reported crime rate increased steadily, and then started to decline. As a matter of fact, in 2013 reported crime rate was at its lowest point since 1969. Furthermore, the homicide
The 1990s in the United States were marked by the incredible drop in crime, a decline in both property crime, and violent crime. The phenomenon was confirmed as “real” versus an artifact of reporting by data generated from the National Victimization Survey (Zimring, 2007). Reasons for the precipitous drop in crime could be because of a booming economy in the United States, and that booming economy certainly accounted for some of the drop-in crime. Incarceration rates also increased in the late 1990s and throughout the 1990s and likely contributed to the drop-in crime (Zimring, 2007).
Violent crime in Canada isn’t too big of a problem in comparison to other countries. In Canada citizens are generally happy to see the police. Rates of corruption are nowhere near what they are in other countries. It is reasonable to say violent crime isn’t as prevalent as it is in America because of the strict gun laws Canada imposes. Also, United States of America has a serious gang problem in comparison to Canada, part of the reason being the shipment of drugs from the southern border. Some examples of violent crimes are assault, aggravated assault, sexual based offences, murder (first and second degree), kidnapping, and robbery. In recent years violent offences has been on the rise in Canada. The types of individuals who commit violent crimes range from gang members to substance abusers. A lot
Violent crimes present in British Columbia seemed to be decreasing between 2012 and 2014 with a 96.04 index in 2012 leading to a 11.58% drop in 2013 however by 2015 there was an increase of 7.43% still only putting the index at 82.99 from 77.25 the previous year (Statistics Canada, 2016). Throughout Canada there has also been a decrease between the years 2012 and 2014 for violent crimes with an 85.72 index in 2012 then going down to 70.50 by 2014 (Statistics Canada, 2016). The biggest drop in those years was again in 2013 with a 9.76% drop though by 2015 it started to increase to a 74.48 index making it a 5.65% change (Statistics Canada, 2016).
Different forms of media, such as television, films, books, and newspapers, have similar ways of portraying the criminal justice system. The media constructs representations of crime and justice and in doing this, it presents an often dramatized representation of the criminal justice system; and this does not just influence on the public’s lay view of crime but also for criminal justice experts (Marsh, 2014). In the media it is commonly known that they are a business, and businesses need to make a profit. Because of this, the media’s portrayal of the criminal justice system has been very negative. With the news, their main purpose is to produce what sells. So many of them would edit the information they have gathered and make a story that will sell. Also the media does not show the full process of the criminal justice as a quick process, while in fact it is not. For example, last year, Netflix released a short series called “Making A Murderer”. Most people claimed that they feel like they can solve a crime when they finished watching a series. While that series is very factual, it does not hit every single step of the criminal justice process.
The goal of this paper is to provide factual information addressing the links to deaths and injuries to different areas around Toronto. Map sources can be used to display and show the changes throughout the past decade to show where activity is taking place. To prove these theories as true, I will use the Toronto Police crime statistics website, review multiple “big name” papers (such as Toronto Star, Globe and Mail, National Post, and The Canadian Press), as well
In the beginning of the 1990s, New York City was filled with violent crime. In the events of recent police shootings, citizens could not help but fear the possibility of the city going back to how it was during the 1990s and earlier violent era times. However, recent studies and reports have indicated that the city has never been as dangerous and violent as it was in earlier times. As by 2015, a modest decrease in the rate of serious reported crimes was noteworthy.
However, recent statistics show Canada’s recent immigrants are better educated, on average, than native-born Canadians (Ceobanu, 2011). Large portions of the people tend to consider immigrants as a large contributor to todays share of crime. While the impact of immigration on crime governs the political debate in most of harboring countries, there is however, very little evidence to support this evidence. Its impact on crime is left unexplored due to the fact that most researchers focus on the impact of immigrants on labor markets (Almeida, Johnson, McNamara & Gupta, 2011). The National Identity however, conducted a survey in 1995 and 2003 by the International Social Survey Programme displaying that people tend to worry that “immigrants increase crime rates” rather than “immigrants take jobs away from natives”(Almeida, Johnson, McNamara & Gupta, 2011). This report hopes to seek the issues set behind immigration and crime. However, there it very little data to convey all views of both sides of the debate. This essay will examine recent sociological studies to attempt to bridge the gap as to why immigrants are seen to be involved in criminal activity. This essay will examine recent sociological studies in order to determine rise in immigrations and a rise in crime rates are positively correlated based on sociological research. To further understand if
When we get into how society and people look at crime, it happens in every city, every neighborhood, people are victims every day, businesses, and even property. Crime dates back since colonization and the rates have varied over time, believe it or not, crime has decreased over the years. As a matter of fact, the United States has been on a decline. The crime rate for the year 2000 was a total of 11,608,072 a declining year in 2015 with a total of 9,225,197. (U.S. Department of Justice)