preview

My Papa Waltz Analysis

Decent Essays

Complexity of My Papa Waltz and Daddy The roles a father plays can be very different from individual to individual. As we dive into the two poems we will see how much these two fathers are really compared and what the role of a father is to a child in their perspective. The two poems I’ve chosen to work with is My Papa Waltz and Daddy. I will say that picking these two poems is a good choice because both of these poems cast a negative view on the father from child’s view even though the child in my Papa Waltz does not resent his father. By comparing the two fathers we will understand why the tones are so alike and different at the same time. Also we will compare and contrast the words in each because each word has a specific meaning that can be misused in several ways. So we will understand a father’s love for a child. First, in these two poems we will see daddy issues and the tones for both of them do compare but at the same time we see a big difference. I will say after reading Daddy that she has major rage towards her father and the tone in the poem is focused on her anger towards him. Looking at My Papa waltz the tone is focused on anger but love for his father is more in depth but feared him. The big difference between the two poems is that both kids have a different view point of their father. Another difference is that the daughter in Daddy is scarred from the emotional abuse, but we see no scarring from the son in My Papa Waltz. I feel that if I lived in one of these poems, I would pick My Papa Waltz because even though my life would be hard, I know I would love my father. Secondly, we will analyze the father in Daddy and compare him to the father in My Papa Waltz. As we analyze the father in Daddy we find out that he emotionally hurt his daughter but never laid a hand on her. With a slight comparison, the father in My Papa Waltz was emotionally hurting his son and beating on him. As we find out that he never resented his father for that because in line (16) “still clinging to your shirt.” To me that sounds like that he still loves his father, even after the wild drinking and that takes guts to keep loving your father after all the bad behavior. From what we know about the daughter in Daddy, she

Get Access