preview

My Grandfather's Knocking Sticks

Decent Essays

Thesis: Brenda Child’s My Grandfather’s Knocking Sticks depicts the consequences settler colonialism has had on the Ojibwe people and how the Ojibwe have attempted to repel such colonialism through acts of sovereignty, especially through wage labor. She incorporates personal family stories with a more broad Ojibwe history to more clearly illustrate the personal effects of colonialism rather than abstract concepts of these changes. Child addresses changes in gender roles and tradition as she argues that “[d]ispossession, poverty, cultural destruction, paternalism, and racism… were [and still are] experienced by Indian people in deeply human ways that always involved a loss of freedom (9-10).” Summary: The first two chapters serve to briefly tell Child’s family history. She explains how her grandparents met, married, and, together, worked to overcome the problems many Ojibwe people faced, like the loss of land and poverty. Her grandfather Fred Auginash, …show more content…

I liked that Child recognized and emphasised the importance of women in their culture, as they are often overlooked in history. Though the main topic was clear, the chapters tended to jump from example to example and were challenging, sometimes even repetitive, and certain points. Her personal history was not necessary and, in my opinion, often took focus away from the Ojibwe community as a whole. These stories, however, did provide concrete examples of Child’s main ideas and helped to fill in the gaps in history as, according to Child, “[o]ther than the occasional meddlesome Indian agents, nobody took time to write about us” (13). Overall, I believe Child was successful in proving her argument; colonialism took away the Ojibwe’s freedom, which they fought to take back and keep, even to this

Get Access