Murder of a Murderer: Murder on the Orient Express by Agatha Christie While murder is widely considered to be the most abhorrent and atrocious act one can commit, Murder on the Orient Express by Agatha Christie takes the dark and tainted act, and raises the question of its’ moral implications. The murder victim in the novel, Mr. Ratchet, has a previous alias, Mr Casetti. He is responsible for the kidnapping and murder of a young girl, Daisy Armstrong. He pretends she is alive, and extorts money from her family for her “safe return”. He blackmails the authorities: allowing him to escape from the deserved punishment. Daisy’s family decides to take matters into their own hands, and seek vengeance for the young girl. The question of whether murder …show more content…
The novel is set at the time of prohibition, however, that does not affect the characters. One of the passengers, Mr Hardman has a suitcase full of alcohol. “The contents of Mr. Hardman's grips were soon examined. They contained perhaps an undue amount of spirituous liquor . Mr Hardman winked. ‘It's not often that they search your grips at the frontiers - not if you fix the conductor. I handed out a wad of Turkish notes right away, and there's been no trouble so far.’” (177). Here is can be seen, that law enforcement officers are flexible in what they do or do not see. Mr Hardman easily skirts around the law, and bypasses all forms of ramifications for his misdeeds. Furthermore, back in America, where prohibition is strictly regulated, Mr. Hardman also evades the law again: “You are not a believer in Prohibition, Monsieur Hardman, said M. Bouc with a smile. Well, said Hardman, I can't say Prohibition has ever worried me any. Ah said M. Bouc ‘The speakeasy.” (177). Hardman finds way to get around the law, simply to fulfill his alcoholic tendencies. The authorities in America are insufficient in catching the owners, as well as the customers, of the illegal speakeasies. This is not the only time when law enforcement is incompetent. Casetti, is not held accountable for the horrendous kidnapping and murder: “Now I will make clear to you this, my friends. Casetti was the man! But by means of the enormous wealth he …show more content…
I’m rejoiced at his end. Such a man wasn’t fit to live” (84). To the passengers, he is as an abominable, cruel and disgusting individual, undeserving of life. His appalling actions outweigh one of the most basic human rights: the right to live. Furthermore Casetti escapes all forms of consequence for his deplorable crimes: “But by means of the enormous wealth he had piled up and by the secret hold he had over various persons, he was acquitted on some technical inaccuracy . . . . He changed his name and left America. Since then he has been a gentleman of leisure, travelling abroad and living on his rentes” (71). Due to him not being held accountable by the law, the Armstrongs and their friends take matters into their own hands. If such a wretched and despicable man could get away with murder, thenthe family have no other option, to punish him for the death of Daisy. Despite having no previous connections to the young girl, Poirot, Dr Constantine, and the director of the Orient Express,Monsieur Bouc, decide to let them go: Poirot looked at his friend. ‘You are the director of the company M. Bouc’ he said, ‘What do you say?’. M. Bouc cleared his throat. In my opinion, M. Poirot’ he said ‘the first theory you put forward was the correct one - decidedly so. I suggest that that is the solution we offer
Prohibition advanced in the 1920’s. However, it did not have an effect on the “liquor-loving public”. Illegal bars, speakeasies, emerged and became well known to the public.
Annotated Bibliography Cohen, D. (1995.) Prohibition america makes alcohol illegal. Brookfield, CT: The Millbrook Press. Daniel Cohen is a very well know children’s fiction writer, which may be very misleading but this book is not fiction. His Alma mater being the University of Illinois at Urbana—Champaign, where he graduated with a degree in journalism.
Corruption and hypocrisy flooded the Congress building rooms and hallways. The men that created the Prohibition law, violated it. In the article The Inside of Prohibition, Mabel Willebrandt provides insight of the corruption through personal experiences. Concealed by the walls of the Congress building, “bootleggers infest the halls and corridors... and ply their trade”. The Congressmen must feel as though they are above the law, constantly “patronizing bootleggers” and “appearing on the floors in a drunken condition”.
The main point of this article is that this story has most classic Christie themes including an enclosed setting (oriented express) and loose associates among suspects. In a detective novel, the suspects usually is much closer to the dead person. But in Murder On The Orient Express, the readers are aware that one after another passengers is connected with the Armstrong kidnapping case. In the end it turns out that everyone has something to hide; however, the criminals are let off scot-free because they have got rid of the world of a monster that law cannot reach,
Prohibition was a period between 1920 and 1932, where vigorous attempts in the United States were made to set laws prohibiting the manufacturing, transport, sale and consumption of alcoholic beverages and spirits, which contributed substantial levels of crime and violence. Ultimately creating a black market for these products. This was only possible through the ratification of Eighteenth Amendment, which legally stated the prohibition of “manufacture, sale, or transit of alcoholic beverages and intoxicating liquors” Crucial factors in this time period played a significant role in characterizing the prohibition era, such as speakeasies which played a vital role in the supply and consumption of illicit liquors by selling dangerous or diluted
Why, and to what extent did the thirteen years of prohibition lead to the rise of organized crime in America? From the year 1920 to the year 1933, the United States of America implemented a nationwide constitutional ban. Under this ban, the 'manufacture, sale, or transportation of intoxicating liquors within, the importation thereof into, or the exportation thereof from the United States' [source 2] was illegal. Prohibition was brought into effect due to a movement from 'dry' crusaders.
Imagine being stuck in one place surrounded by many strangers, one of whom have been killing people the others one by one. Commentary. And Then There Were None, by Agatha Christie explores that very idea. The guests on the island must try to avoid becoming the killer's next victim by using strategy and wit. Commentary. HarperCollins Publishers published this book along with many other of Agatha Christie's books. Commentary. The website goodreads.com gives this book 4/5 stars and Barns and Noble gives this book 4.5/5 stars. Commentary. If you are unfamiliar with this book or Agatha Christie’s books, you could compare reading the books almost to watching a horror movie. Commentary. I choose to read this book because it was recommended to me by a teacher. Commentary. If somebody were to ask me how I felt about this book, I would pass along the recommendation I was given and sing only praises of this book. Commentary.
And then there were none by Agatha Christie is a bestselling mystery novel about ten strangers that get lured to an island by a physically unknown person or persons, in this book they arrive at the island but each night one of them is murdered, thus leaving no one in the end, as the title infers. But, there are characters that the author may have felt sympathy for, such as Mrs. Rogers, Captain Lombard, and the judge. Mrs. Rogers seems terrified and shaky, almost as if she knows she is going to die. Captain Lombard is a somewhat cocky yet humble man with low expectations in life. The judge is an angry old man who is very suspicious but he has his perks I suppose. Out of all the characters the readers
Life is not fair to everybody. Most people learn this before they even reach their teenage years. Sometimes things work out well for some people, but not so much for others. Laws and regulations passed and enforced by the government can greatly affect how things work out for people. It has happened where people who should have had consequences from breaking the law have gotten off scot-free because the way the justice system is set up. When this happens, some people have been known to take control of the situation themselves and do what they think is morally right. In both And Then There Were None and Murder on the Orient Express, Agatha Christie uses plot to reveal that the administration of justice by the government is not always fair
The 18th amendment allegedly took the licenses from business owners, and jobs from working people, as the manufacturing and sale of alcohol was now prohibited. However, the 18th amendment never mentioned the consumption of liquor, making it acceptable to drink the alcohol that was previously bought before the amendment became effective. During prohibition, the craving of alcohol did not diminish as society was in a constant need of illegal alcohol, this laid the foundation of bootleggers to thrive. “Bootleggers began smuggling foreign-made commercial liquor into the United States from across the Canadian and Mexican borders and along the seacoasts from ships under foreign registry.” (Kerr 11) Bootleggers began to sell to anyone willing to purchase the illegal and imported alcohol, specifically the gangsters, also known as the mobsters. Under the circumstances that caused bootlegging and the selling alcohol illegally, it caused many people to turn to speakeasies. Speakeasies were illegal drinking dens, also known as saloons, that where found underground. “The people involved with speakeasies mainly
This paper will present a compare and contrast of the short story, "Witness for the Prosecution" to the screenplay of the same name written by Agatha Christie. The focus of the similarities and differences will be, a review of the characters and the story.
Murder on the Orient Express by Agatha Christie is a murder-mystery novel that takes place on a train headed toward Calais. In the middle of the 2nd night aboard, the train comes to a halt, and the passengers are stuck in a snowstorm. It is then discovered that a man has been murdered, and everyone in the train is now a suspect. The novel follows Hercule Poirot as he examines the evidence and tries to piece together the story behind the murder. Throughout the novel, the theme of justice is very important because it is repeatedly mentioned, it was initially evaded by the victim, and is revealed to be the inspiration behind the murder.
Many believed that the Prohibition Law would prevent crimes, and the sale/consumption of alcohol, in reality it did the exact opposite. Prohibition led to the bootlegging businesses, the thrill of alcohol, and the creation of speakeasies or blind pigs. Speakeasies were created to illegally sell alcoholic beverages during Prohibition (Smuggling). Speakeasies were found everywhere in Canada, whether hidden in a store or business, in every urban establishment there was an illegal party near (Smuggling). The speakeasies were exciting for Canadians, because they were still able to have fun at local bars. However they had to be sneaky, which made the experience even better. The Smuggling buisness was very profitable, and those smuggling had average jobs, however it was risky (Bos). This job was very exciting for Canadians, because it was a way to make a lot of money by doing something so simple. People ignored the laws that were designed to keep them from transporting, selling, and consuming alcohol (Jen). This was exciting for Canadians, because when they ignored the laws it gave them a thrill or an adrenaline rush, which allowed them to let loose and have more fun. Many Canadians took advantage of the Prohibition Law, as the years went
Morals are principles which help people to behave rightly. Also, they need to protect the rules. However, in Agatha Christie’s novel, Murder on the Orient Express, the characters act dishonestly: twelve passengers on the Orient Express murder Cassetti, they lie to the Belgian private detective, Hercule Poirot and the protagonist overlooks the passengers. Agatha Christie wrote these intensions fairly. From Murder on the Orient Express, the readers can learn that some set of morals are endorsed.
Murder on the Orient Express is more than just a murder mystery. It is a novel that utilizes a great deal of existing social issues of the era in which it was written and formed a commentary on those issues while giving the reader an intriguing yet approachable narrative. Through this approach, Agatha Christie has given the reader an opportunity to see the world through the eyes of the seasoned private investigator Hercule Poirot. In this world, nothing is at it seems and apparent coincidence belies a hidden truth, a world in which the geographical connections created by passenger railways allowed people of different nationalities and classes to rub elbows.