preview

Mr Heart Deliberation

Decent Essays

Have you ever given money to someone to take care of a loved one? We give them shelter, food, and most importantly our trust. But do you know what we get in return, instead of a good healthy sign of wellness in our loved one, we get a cold blooded murder. Mr. Heart was a caretaker for Mr. Dan and could get access into every room in the home, especially the room of the Mr. Dan, where he sat and watched him, until the eighth night where he killed him. Pretty peculiar huh? Well, ladies and gentlemen of the jury, today we are here for the case of Mr. Heart v. The State of New Jersey, we have taken the time to gather powerful evidence that will prevail the decision in this case such as premeditation, deliberation, and malice that all prove that …show more content…

Heart confessed his side of deliberation in his testimony, which concludes that not only we have premeditation on him but also deliberation against him. First of all, what is the denotation of deliberate? Deliberation means a carefully weighed; studied; intentional consideration. An example of deliberation is when Mr. Heart’s Testimony says “You should have seen how wisely I proceeded - with what caution ----- with what foresight ---- with what dissimulation I work”(Poe 1). This shows that Mr. Heart was very conscientious about what he was doing making sure Mr. Dan wouldn’t hear him while asleep. Another statement in Mr. Heart’s Testimony that shows deliberation is, “Upon the eighth night I was more than usually cautious in opening the door. A watch’s minute hand moved more quickly then did mine. Never before that night had I felt the extent of my own powers of my sagacity”(Poe 2 ). To explain this, Mr. Heart was very meticulous in how he was entering the room upon the eighth night since he was planning on carrying out the murder then and Mr. Heart claims he has sagacity during all of this. What is sagacity, you may ask? Sagacity is wisdom, like quick and wise in understanding judgement: kind of based off on the denotation of the word prudent which also means wise. All of this evidence shows how guilty Mr. Heart is and how much he should be thrown in jail for first degree murder but for some reason nothing has been done to punish this …show more content…

Heart to prison is malice. What is malice you may ask? The word malice defines; that there was an intent to hurt someone, like you specifically had a motive to want that person dead. And for Mr. Heart to actually murder the innocent it shows the reason of malice, that should make Mr. Heart be held in jail for murder in the first degree. Another example of malice is in Mr. Heart’s very own testimony,“ He had never given me insult. For his gold I had no desire. I think it was his eye! Yes, it was this! He had the eye of a vulture -- a pale blue eye, with a film over it. Whenever it fell upon me, my blood ran cold”(Poe 1). This shows that he had a motive which was to “rid myself from the evil eye”(Poe 1). An eye is not a valid reason to kill someone, it just shows that he is coward to face a fear of an eyeball, not even a real person. Mr. Heart may have been very emotional during all of this but it does not prove that he is insane, the man was sane when he killed the man, he even hid the gruesome body under the floorboards; but when the police came he becomes insane because the beating of the heart. Ladies and gentleman you solve the puzzle, this man’s

Get Access