preview

Mistaken Identity By Sharon E. Cooper: Play Analysis

Decent Essays

Critical Thinking: How Perspective Can Resolve Conflict People are more likely to make rational decisions when they are not blinded by emotion. This intangible decision making tool is called critical thinking. It is one’s ability to recognize a conflict or opportunity, and evaluate all the possible circumstances before proceeding. That is how individuals establish their perspective of the world and the people living in it. In the absence of critical thinking, one may impose a single-minded approach to any situation, which, at times, can result in conflict. Obtaining perspective can enable a person to achieve understanding and resolve conflicts. This is demonstrated in Mistaken Identity, a play written by Sharon E. Cooper. The short play takes …show more content…

A critical point in the play would be when Kali states, “In the meantime, I’ll continue to be a loud, abrasive lesbian while my brother sets me up with every bloke on the street – and they don’t even have to be Hindu anymore! Do you have any idea what that’s like? How would you know?” (862). Steve agrees that he would not know, which gives the characters a basis for mutual understanding. By enlightening Steve of her awkward position in the situation, Steve is able to gain some perspective and therefore feels more compassionate towards Kali rather than conflicted. Towards the end, Kali explains why she cannot confess to her family of her homosexuality, claiming, “I can’t say, Mum, Daddy, Rashid, I’ve chose women over men – it’s not a hamburger over fish. You just don’t know how they’ll react. I’d run the risk of not being allowed to see my nieces. I’m so exhausted from hiding, I can barely breathe.” (864), which offers Steve and the reader insight on Kali’s feelings and how she feels in conflict with herself. Beyond this point, the conflict between Kali and Steve no longer exists as they have managed to gather enough perspective from one another to resolve the misunderstanding. However, to no extent are the personal conflicts in this play resolved. Kali is still trapped in a life where she is unable to attain happiness due to cultural expectations and Steve remains to be the desperate thirty-two year old student trying to figure out what to do with his life. Perhaps she tells him she is a homosexual because deep down she wants her brother to know and unlike her previous dates, Steve is not Hindu, so she believes that he would be more accepting of her bearings. Steve is desperate for the idea of marriage because he sees it as a self-fulfilling prophecy or salvation from his underwhelming ordinary

Get Access