preview

Mccutcheon

Decent Essays

According to Russel McCutcheon, the academic study of religion emphasizes two main points. These two elements of analysis are historical accuracy and descriptive accuracy (McCutcheon, 1). Ideally, this approach to the study of religion should be completely neutral. Theology, on the other hand, may accentuate a particular viewpoint or method of living that is consistent with the religion being studied. The approach that McCutcheon describes is also utilized by Brown throughout the first chapter of his book. This is evident due to the plethora of examples which describe the branches of the Islamic people, and the different set of beliefs that come with it. In the first chapter, Brown does not adhere to a particular form of Islam. Instead, he is trying to present the various beliefs and historical events that have coalesced into modern-day Islam. One of the focal points that Brown aims to showcase is that the Islamic religion …show more content…

Unlike theological study, Brown is not trying to determine which group has greater veracity to it. He is simply pointing out the distinctions between the two. According to Brown, the main reasons for the division stemmed from a disagreement regarding “leadership and authority within the umma” (Brown, 9). This discord in the Muslim community is what led to the formation of the Sunnis and Shiites when it was time to appoint a successor for Muhammad. Another reason to suspect that Brown’s approach to Islam is similar to McCutcheon’s approach to studying religion is predicated on the expectation towards the end of the first chapter. “How Islam came to be what it is today in all of its variety and its paradoxical unity - is the story I have set out to tell in this book” (Brown, 15). This statement is important because it allows us to understand that Brown’s focus will be on the history of Islam, and how its history shaped the religion that we see

Get Access