preview

Martin Luther King Research Paper

Decent Essays

In 1996 Samuel Mohammed, a resident of West Palm Beach community, kicked down the door of an abandoned house within his neighborhood, that was used as a drug house, spread lighter fluid and started a fire. The night he set the fire he was never far away from the scene. He stood by and watched as the fire and at the time he deemed appropriate he called the police and the fire station. In response for setting the fire he was arrested on the charge of arson. His lawyer argued that he was not practicing arson but he was practicing Civil Disobedience in the traditional of Martin Luther King Jr. The question the jury was faced was should he be punished as an arsonist or let slide for practicing Civil Disobedience. He should be charged with arson …show more content…

Black Law Dictionary defines civil disobedience as “the refusal to obey a law because it is unjust or it is unfair and it is usually nonviolent in behavior.” Florida’s law against arson in the 1997 Florida Statutes section 806.01 one part a that pertains to arson states that “Any person who willfully and unlawfully, or while in the commission of any felony, by fire or explosion, damages or causes to be damaged: (a) Any dwelling, whether occupied or not, or its contents.” Mohammed did start a fire and did cause damage to a unoccupied dwelling. He broke the law, but in order for him to be practicing civil disobedience he would have to have broken the law because it was unfair or unjust. If in face he thought that it was an unfair law why did he state his reasons for starting the fire as he and his neighbors were tired of the police not doing their job punishing the criminals that frequented the house ()? If somebody torched his unoccupied house while he was on vacation he could not be upset because he believed the law against arson was unfair. His reason for starting the fire was not civil disobedience it was

Get Access