preview

Magic In Diana Bishop's Misconceptions

Decent Essays

According to the Oxford Dictionaries, one can define magic as “the power of apparently influencing events" by means of "mysterious or supernatural forces” (Oxford). Due to the growing influence of scientific advancement in the past decades, the polysemic term “magic” appears to have lost its enigmatic and supernatural connotations. Rather, magical beliefs and supernatural phenomenon have predominantly been replaced by scientific theories and explanations, with people believing that all magical phenomenon can be explained through science. The character development of Deborah Harkness' protagonist, Diana Bishop, and the characterization of the deuterogamist, Matthew Clairmont, reference the varying views that people have today toward scientific …show more content…

However, historical texts and records show that magic and science actually compliment one another, especially during the early fourteenth century and the Middle Ages, since magic and science often shared “common intellectual underpinnings” (Hansen). After her parents' horrific murder during her childhood, Diana secluded herself from her magical origin and makes it her mission to exclude magic from her life. Diana explains, “ ‘I wanted to know how humans came up with a view of the world that had so little magic in it...I needed to understand how they convinced themselves that magic wasn’t important’ ”(Harkness 73). Diana purposefully chose to study the history of science because she hopes that science, particularly alchemy, will help her to convince herself that magic has no significant hold on the world in which she resides. Despite being a naturally gifted witch, Diana's refusal to acknowledge the presence of magic in her daily life exemplifies the growing attitude that modern society generally has toward magic. Today, society tends to have a more realistic mind-frame for any subject that involves a mystery or natural phenomenon, yet if one looks back into the history of science, modern science stems from alchemy and the unfeasible ideas that it …show more content…

Diana's research of seventeenth-century alchemy, Harkness elaborates on the widespread fallacy of alchemy to explaining the reasoning behind why certain individuals cannot understand the interweaving relationship between magic and science. After Matthew expresses his admiration toward Diana's work, Diana struggles to understand his admiration since to her, “it seemed highly unlikely” that Matthew, a professor of biochemistry, would be interested in seventeenth-century alchemy (Harkness 20). Modern science, such as chemistry, will often be considered contradicting toward alchemy since chemistry represents modern experimental science while alchemy represents that of the supernatural and unrealistic. History and chemistry professors, William R. Newman and Lawrence M. Príncipe, explain that the distinction between alchemy and chemistry today originates from a “historiographic mistake” that occurred as a result of the presumption that the distinction between the two disciplines stems back all the way to the seventeenth century. Furthermore, modern secondary literature further endorses the “historiographic mistake” by claiming that the words chemistry and alchemy “were commonly used at that time” to reference the distinction between the

Get Access