preview

Love Is A Fallacy Analysis

Decent Essays

Max Shulman’s piece, “Love is a fallacy” expresses many arguments expressed during every day social interactions. In the piece, the author comes into contact with his roommate, Petey Bellows and a possible love interest, Polly Espy. The author makes many unjustified guess pertaining to their wisdom and intelligence, and these false pretenses contribute to his interactions with the two, and he aims to take advantage of the opportunity of manipulating the two into achieving his own selfish desires. His plan backfires, and he is forced to reconsider his actions. In the process, Max Shulman reveals that his piece is both anti-women, anti-men, and Shulman underestimates the intuitive and emotional aspects of love.
In his judgement of the women in the piece, Polly Espy, Shulman uses mostly a natural reasoning to come to unjustified conclusions about her. In the very beginning of the piece, Shulman has already come to the conclusion that Espy is not intelligent, based on a very limited amount of actual interaction with her. He does not give much reasoning to support the claim, other than he just knows. Once he actually converses with her to let her express herself, he assesses her as unintelligent based off faulty reasoning. For instance, because Espy shortens her words such as, “terrif” he views her as a simple minded woman who may not have the capacity for rational thought. However, she may truly be brilliant, but Shulman jumps to bad conclusions based on the way she talks and/or

Get Access