preview

Louis Pojman The Philosophy Of Death Summary

Decent Essays

In "What is Death? The Crisis of Criteria" Louis Pojman introduced four definitions of death and describes their benefits and limitations. The four definitions include loss of the soul, cardiopulmonary failure, whole brain death and neocortical brain death, of which the cardiopulmonary is typically most common. I intend to show, using the work of Jonathan Glover and reasoning, that the neocortical brain death definition holds significant merit and is truly more practical and ethical. The neocortical brain death definition suggests that death occurs when the cerebrum or upper brain dies, eliminating speech, consciousness and thought; basically, an individual is dead when their personality dies. The trouble here is that an individual who has …show more content…

This poses a challenge for the neocortical view, but has the potential to be remedied. "It may be objected that, in ordinary language, it makes sense to say of someone that he is irreversibly comatose but still alive. This must be admitted. … Do we value "life" even if unconscious, or do we value life only as a vehicle for consciousness? Our attitude to the doctrine of the sanctity of life very much depends on our answer to this question." (Glover, The Philosophy of Death, pg. 349) Is this a life worth living just for the sake of it? Glover points out that it is dangerous to separate lives into "worth living" and "not worth living", however, it appears as though society has reached a point at which this very distinction is being made in certain cases. Cases for euthanasia argue that an individual's suffering is capable of escalating to the point that death would be preferable over further pain and/or deterioration; examples include individuals who suffer severely from ALS, Huntington's Disease, various forms of cancer, etc. Although an individual who has experience neocortical brain death does not feel constant pain as a direct consequence of upper brain death, the process of sustaining the body is incredibly harsh and painful. This pain increases exponentially if said patient has opted to forgo any extraordinary measures and must be left to die of their own accord. Even with medical intervention the patient is at increased risk of contractors (which cause the hands and feet to curl and lose function), tissue breakdown, bed sores, sepsis, shock, bloodlust and many other afflictions that would eventually lead to death. For this reason, it seems clear that the value of being alive is not worth allowing the persistence of unconscious and, consequentially, a painful

Get Access