preview

Lets Put Pornography Back In The Closet Analysis

Decent Essays

What is pornography? According to the dictionary pornography means “Obscene writings, drawings, photographs”. Yet, many people disagree with what is consider to be pornography in society today. Susan Brownmiller is a feminist activist who wrote an essay “ Lets Put Pornography Back in the Closet” argues that pornography should be not be protect by the 1st Amendment or be allowed into society. Meanwhile, Susan Jacoby a writer of “ A First Amendment Junkie” disagrees with Brownmiller because she believes that it’s everyone’s right and that society should not be able to censor pornography. Should society let the government censor pornography just because we may not approve this type of act. I agree with both of the writer’s that pornography should …show more content…

Many people say that pornography should be censors and other say that it is helpful. Pornography is used all around the world for many reason whether if its use for masturbation, other use it to release stress or for there personal needs and it may help relationships. Brownmiller states “pornography represents hatred of women, that hat pornography’s intent is to humiliate, degrade, and dehumanize the female body for the purpose to erotic stimulation and pleasure” (62). So what Brownmiller is saying is that because of pornography women are targeted and hated by many and this is why it should be censor. I disagree with her because pornography does not bring women down nor is it only used for pleasure. This example says the opposite to what Brownmiller said, “pornography, for example, doesn’t degrade women; women are degraded by our culture, and certain forms of pornography reflect that.” (McWilliams). McWilliams states that pornography isn’t the one who is degrading women but who is really humiliating women is ones culture. Our culture is the one who is corrupting the society and not pornography. I agree with McWilliams that society should be the one who is censor and not pornography. Because as a society we are the one who is hurting …show more content…

An example is “In many repressive countries—whether in Central America, Asia, Africa, Eastern Europe, or the Middle East, there is practically no pornography, but there is a great deal of sexism and violence against women –and men.” (Dority). Dority explains that pornography is not the problem of violence in a society where there isn’t any pornography. Another example is “Sexism and violence toward women, and men, was a reality long before pornography as we know it today existed and long before there were facilities for the mass distribution of words and images. Sexist and violent materials are symptoms of a sexist and violent society – not the causes.”(Dority). Dority states that pornography isn’t the problem because sexism and violence where there first before pornography. People are the ones who created an environment that was use to violent and sexism so they try to put the blame on porno because it is the easy way out. If we see that in other countries pornography isn’t the problem from violent or sexism, then why should we censor something that isn’t causing any problems?
First Amendment is freedom of speech, press, religion, peacefully assemble. McWilliams states “With censorship, we find another conservative-liberal division over which activity justifies “bending” the First Amendment. When either side wants to censor, conservatives usually want to censor the sexual; liberals generally want to censor violence.”(1). He states

Get Access