| Krispy Kreme Doughnuts Case | Seminar in Finance | | Gregory Steigerwalt | 4/17/2012 |
|
Krispy Kreme Case – Discussant
Krispy Kreme’s rapid expansion may have been the reason for its rapid fall. Recently becoming a publicly traded company in April 2000, Krispy Kreme shares had seen amazing growth as they were selling for 62 times earnings. Naturally, this created a buzz around Wall Street, and an “obsession” with Krispy Kreme began as it became one of the hottest stocks on the market. Yet, analysis of the fundamentals of Krispy Kreme needed to by analyzed to see the true threats the company had brought upon itself.
Analysis of Krispy Kreme’s business model and strategy gives a good insight as to how the company
…show more content…
The first problem came about on May 7th, 2004 when Krispy Kreme announced adverse results for the first time. This announcement was only the tip of the iceberg as shortly after the Wall Street Journal published an article about the aggressive accounting Krispy Kreme used for reacquired franchises.
The actions being criticized within the article involved Krispy Kreme’s negotiations to purchase a seven-store Michigan franchise. The franchise had been struggling, and owed Krispy Kreme several millions of dollars in franchise fees, for equipment, and ingredients. The settled deal required the franchise chain to pay the accrued interest on past-due loans in return for a raise in the acquisition price. This interest was then recorded as interest income and thus was immediate profit for Krispy Kreme. The price to acquire the franchise was booked as an intangible asset which was not amortized. Moreover, the executive of the seven-store chain was allowed to stay on after the purchase, but the executive left shortly after, and Krispy Kreme had to pay $5 million in severances which was also recorded as an unamortized asset.
Looking at it from the market perspective, Krispy Kreme was in the minority with how they treated their accounting
The article that I read was called “Baskin-Robbins Franchisee, Hugh Williams” which I will also cite below in further detail. It is a short yet very interesting article about a franchisee named Hugh Williams who was given licensing to open up his own Baskin-Robbins. The article starts out by talking about a little of his background information and how he worked for his parents Baskin-Robbins when he was younger. What is interesting is how he had the dream to open up his own when he got older and he made it happen. He actually graduated from Georgia Tech with an engineering degree which is not something you would expect from the franchisee of an ice cream shop. Even with his love for Baskin-Robbins he still was unsure of himself and he actually sold his shops in 1997 in pursuit of a different career. However he found himself going back to the small ice cream shop as he missed the simplicity of owning one. Hugh eventually became a multi-unit
As the rising District Manager for the new Dunkin’ Donuts stores, many factors must be presented, analyzed, promoted, and executed. Opening new stores requires innovative ideas, being ahead of the game with the newest trends, and stabilizing the stores for the least amount of turnovers. Managing stores also means maintaining respect while coaching is vital. This requires feedback on both upward and downward channels of communication. For the purpose of this paper, Dunkin’ Donuts will be assessed and evaluated based on its job and organizational designs, criteria for recruiting and
Krispy Kreme executives no longer rush to implement new plans before the time is right. They carefully study each geographical location to make sure its market will support a full-scale doughnut operation. Also, management spends time checking out sites for individual stores. Potential franchisee and employees are required to maintain certain standards and are thoroughly screened.
Dunkin’ Donuts has over six-thousand locations in the United States and serves over three and a half million customers daily. The biggest competitor for Dunkin’ Donuts are Peet’s Coffee & Tea, Starbucks, and McDonalds. In order to maintain market competitiveness Dunkin’ Donuts must remain driven towards service excellence. This starts by hiring staff members that are eager to provide the best customer service with every interaction they have and be able to produce an excellent product. “Dunkin’ Brand offers a comprehensive series of award-winning training programs for crew members, managers and franchises designed to foster deep connections to our brands’ heritage and improve the guest experience and business results at the restaurant level.” (Schmidt,R.A & Oldfield, B.M. 1999) Bill Rosenberg the founder of Dunkin’ Donuts operates by a simple philosophy but one that is carried through each store. “Make and serve the freshest, most delicious coffee and donuts quickly and courteously in modern well-merchandised stores” (Dunkin Donuts, n.d., pp. 1) Being a new district manager tasked with opening five new locations will help fulfill Rosenberg’s vision of providing the best product around in a courteous environment both for staff and customers. This paper will focus on job design, organizational design, recruiting and selecting, training personnel and performance appraisal are key elements in the success of opening five new locations.
When looking at the 2004 DuPont analysis, you see that not only has profit margin increased every year, but it is more than 2% better than the industry average. That being said, Krispy Kreme does not utilize its assets as efficiently as its competitors. This potentially troubling because of the fact that they have gone through aggressive growth in stores recently. Is this an indication that these stores are not generating the sales necessary to justify the investment, or at least as well as its competitors might be able to? Finally the equity multiplier comes in below the industry average. To us this means that Krispy Kreme does not utilize its leverage as effectively as the competition. Perhaps it would be to Krispy Kreme’s benefit to increase leverage and invest in order to increase growth and earnings in a similar manner to its competition. Overall, we believe that Krispy Kreme is moderately
The Krispy Kreme Doughnuts case study solution solves the case on financial statement analysis. The structure of the solution is outlined below and answers the questions included in the outline
The whole process throughput time of making a dozen of cookies is 26 minutes. It takes washing, mixing and spooning 8 minutes to make a dozen of cookies. And preparation and bake time totally are 10 minutes. The final step of cooling, packing and accepting payment of cookies takes roommate 8 minutes to finish the cycle. Assume the night capacity is 4 hours, so Kristen and roommate have 240 minutes operating time. Since the oven only holds one tray, the second dozen takes an additional 10 minutes to bake. For example, first dozen of cookies take 26 minutes to make, second dozen of cookies take 36 minutes to make and third dozen of cookies take 46 minutes to make. So we can
Dunkin’ Donuts was established by Bill Rosenberg in 1950 in Quincy, MA. Dunkin’ Donuts started license franchises in 1955. It is the world’s leading baked goods and coffee chains serving more than 3 million customers per day. Dunkin’ Donut sells 52 varieties of donuts and more than a dozen coffee beverages as well as an array of bagels, breakfast sandwiches, and baked goods. At the end of 2010, there were 9,760 franchises all over the
As Wall Street Journal stated, Krispy Kreme grew too quickly and diluted its cult status by selling its doughnut in too many outlets. They could not anticipate when the demand decreased due to low-carbohydrate diet trend issues. It can be seen clearly that interest expenses also increased for the year ended Feb 2, 2003 to the year ended Feb 1, 2004 as the debt increased.
The company under analysis in this report is Dunkin Donuts. The brand of Dunkin Donuts originated in 1950 when Bill Rosenberg opened the very first outlet in Massachusetts, USA. Today Dunkin' Donuts is the world's leading baked goods and coffee chain, serving more than 3 million customers per day worldwide. It sells about 52 varieties of donuts and more than a dozen coffee beverages as well as an array of bagels, breakfast, sandwiches, subs and other baked goods. Dunkin Donuts is a subsidiary company of Dunkin Brands Inc that owns companies like Dunkin Donuts, Baskin Robins etc. Dunkin Donuts is a multinational company with its presence in more than 32 nations. By the end of 2011, there were 10,083 Dunkin' Donuts stores worldwide that included 7,015 franchised restaurants in the United States of America and 3,068 international outlets in more than 32 countries across the globe employing more than 9000 people. According to the financial report published by Dunkin Brands Inc, the parent company of Dunkin Donuts the net sales worldwide totaled up to $8.77 billion, up 5.2 percent from the previous year and the Net income for the year was $108.3 million, up 214.5 percent as reported by the company.
1. In the beginning, how was Starbucks different from other coffee options for coffee drinkers in the United States? What activities and assets did Starbucks leverage to differentiate itself from competitors?
KRISPY KREME, one of the successful companies in the food-service industry, began as a single doughnut shop in the early 20ths. The rapid expansion of its business scale made the corporation suffer its first economic crisis by the early 1980s. A group of franchisees later took charge of the heavily-debt company bringing new management ideas which helped the KRISPY KREME find way back to the game and become the role model in the industry. KK generated revenues through four primary sources: on-premises retail sales, off-premises sales, product mix and
Krispy Kreme Doughnuts was a successful privately owned business since 1937. In 1982 a group of franchises bought back the company from Beatrice Foods for $24 million, and reintroduced the old recipe of doughnuts and their “hot doughnuts now” system. In 1998 Scott Livengood became Krispy Kreme’s new
Krispy Kreme is a branded specialty retailer and manufacturer of premium quality doughnuts. Its principal business is to own and franchise Krispy Kreme doughnut stores in the U.S. and internationally. The main product is the Hot Original Glazed, a one-of-a-kind doughnut with an established brand. Each outlet also sells over 20 other varieties of doughnuts and coffee products. Product quality and consistency has provided the Company with a very loyal customer base.3
People love to drink coffee. Coffee shops, independently owned or chains are every corner. Statistics show that people are taking more coffee every day. It is a very profitable business.