To Kill a Mockingbird and The Secret Life of Bees
By: Pawanpreet Mundi
Every novel in the English literature has similarities and differences to another. The comparison between the novels is judged from topics such as the setting, laws, characters and daily living. The novel, To Kill a Mockingbird by Harper Lee has many similarities and differences with the novel, The Secret Life of Bees by Sue Monk Kidd. Both novels are comparative as the characters in the books, their relationships and community laws portrayed are very similar and different to each other. The following examples and explanations prove that the authors of both novels are trying to convey similar yet different messages. In view of that, relationships between characters in ‘To Kill a Mockingbird’ are clearly similar and different to ‘The Secret of Bees’. Lily explains her relationship by saying, “Rosaleen had worked for us since my mother died. My daddy– who I called T. Ray because ‘Daddy’ never fit him” (2). This quotation from ‘The Secret Life of Bees’ is by Lily, narrating her relationship with Rosaleen and T. Ray. Rosaleen treats Lily like her daughter as she compliments Lily and gives advice on her decision of fashion school. Comparatively, when Lily tells her father T. Ray about the swarm of bees in her room, T. Ray does not believe her daughter and instead threatens punishment. This quote states Rosaleen genuinely cares for Lily as she thinks for her best while T. Ray does not treat her own
One of which was at the very beginning of the movie. The opening scene of the movie was Lily’s hazy memory of her picking up the gun to hand to her mother when she accidentally shot her. Then, it goes to Lily thinking to herself before she falls asleep which is how the book starts. In the book, Lily is thinking to herself before she falls asleep, and she is explaining to us her obsession with bees where she also tells us the time period of the whole story, the summer of 1964. The author of The Secret Life of Bees, Sue Monk Kidd, doesn't get into Lily’s memory until after Lily goes to get T. Ray to show him the bees swarming in her room. The next difference is how T. Ray realized that Lily was in Tiburon and how he tracked her down. In the book he saw the number that Lily called him with earlier in the story on his phone bill because she made a collect call. He then called that number and the owner filled him in on where Kily his daughter was. In the movie, T. Ray saw a small hole in the wall where Lily used to have a map of South Carolina. He put the map back up and put a tack where the hole was and it lined up with Tiburon. Another difference in the movie is that Rosaleen isn't as confident, knowledgeable, or assertive as she seems in the book. At the start of the book, Rosaleen is a role model for Lily that tries to give her meaningful life teachings and she also seems older. In the movie however, she is much younger than she seems and way more soft spoken. Lastly, T. Ray isn't as mean and abusive as he is in the book. He isn't as much of a hot head as he was in the book. It seems like the character’s personality was changed for the movie almost as if to show that he tried not to lose his head as much as before once Deborah was gone. These differences are in the movie because they were things that were not really necessary for
Lily and Rosaleen throughout the book and the movie seem to have a good relationship. Lily’s mother past away at an early age, Rosaleen was the only female influenced in Lily’s life. Rosaleen helps Lily adapt to her childhood and becomes her only resource information her work has been pretty hard she needs to be like a mother to Lily. Lily and Rosaleen were very close, and although Rosaleen has been the family housekeeper, she always stays with lily and supports her throughout the novel. According to the secret life of bee’s, Lily was motherless and Rosaleen is the adult female in the household, she would always take care of Lily, cooking meals and maintaining the house. She gives Lily love, rescuing Lily from her father’s extreme punishment
An informed written analysis and evaluation of a piece of work is known as literary criticism, and it is often based on literary theory. One literary theory technique is intertextual criticism, which allows the reader to acknowledge similarities between literature. Throughout Harper Lee’s fictitious novel To Kill A Mockingbird, and the historical fiction novel A Separate Peace by John Knowles, the authors take advantage of intertextual criticism to identify universal themes and symbols within their work. Both novels display similarities when they incorporate a tree as a symbol of friendship, the child archetype and the loss of innocence.
According to the National Runaway Safeline, between 1.6 and 2.8 million teenagers run away from home every year. Each of these teenagers has different reasons for running away, but lots often run away because of parental abuse. Lily Owens is no different from these runaway teens. In the Secret Life of Bees by Sue Monk Kidd, the reader meets Lily,14 year old girl searching for answers to her mother's death. When her father refuses to provide her with answers and continually abuses her, Lily has no choice but to seek answers on her own. Lily follows in her mother's footsteps looking for answers and runs away to do so. In the process Lily finds three women who her mother had come across and forms a bond with them in order to find answers
Harper Lee's To Kill a Mockingbird is a highly regarded work of American fiction. The story of the novel teaches us many lessons that should last any reader for a lifetime. The messages that Harper Lee relays to the reader are exemplified throughout the book using various methods. One of the most important and significant methods was the use of symbols such as the mockingbird image. Another important method was showing the view through a growing child's (Scout Finch) mind, eyes, ears, and mouth. There is another very significant method that was used. In the novel, To Kill a Mockingbird, Harper Lee utilizes the effects of irony, sarcasm, and hypocrisy to criticize a variety of elements in Southern life.
“People can start out one way, and by the time life gets through with them they end up completely different. I don’t doubt he started off loving your mother. In fact, I think he worshipped her” (Kidd, 248). Towards the beginning of the book, The Secret Life of Bees, T. Ray was perceived as an unsympathetic character. He would order Lily to do things around the house, and if she ever did anything wrong, he would either beat her or make her kneel on grits which is supposed to be very painful. Although his character is not the best readers can begin to understand why T. Ray turned out to be what he was. Deborah, T. Ray’s wife, ran away from him because she did not love him as much as he loved her. Also, T. Ray was forced to take care of their daughter, Lily, who reminded him every day of Deborah because Lily was the spitting image of her. Alongside that, Lily runs away from T. Ray, which makes him realize what he has been doing to her. Despite the fact that T. Ray treated Lily horribly, one would view
Throughout history, there has been an overarching theme that writers write about. Great authors write about what they know. They write about what they see. They write about what they hear. They write about personal experiences and incorporate details from their lives into their literature. Harper Lee’s To Kill a Mockingbird is a classical work that reflects the Civil Rights and Women’s Movement of the 1950’s-1960’s through her depiction of the relationship between blacks and whites and her portrayal of female characters.
“I note the obvious differences between each sort and type, but we are more alike, my friends, than we are unalike (Maya Angelou).” This quote although wise is not revolutionary nor complex. Instead accomplished poet and writer, Maya Angelou, is simply trying to convey how differences don’t actually make us different. This statement became all the more accurate when I found myself relating to Scout, a six year old girl from Maycomb, Alabama, who I once perceived as my polar opposite. Instead, as my understanding of the novel progressed, I realized that we more parallel than I ever could have ever imagined. Harper Lee’s To Kill a Mocking Bird proves that fictional books can definitely be identical to real life. Both Scout and I are precocious, curious, and quite spirited young ladies.
Mother Appreciation Everyday Every morning when my mother wakes me up to get ready for a long day of school, I don’t appreciate it. I don’t appreciate all the little things she does for me and there is a lot of them. In the novel The Secret Life of Bees, by Sue Monk Kidd, Lily has no one left but her babysitter. They ran away together from her abusive father to Tiburon South Carolina because her mother left a picture with that specific location on it.
With over 30 million copies sold in 40 different languages, To Kill a Mockingbird remains at the top of bestselling novels. Furthermore, it is taught in over three-fourths of American high schools for good reason. In order for any novel to be considered a “timeless classic,” it must contain characters relatable to the audience through the purposeful use of their morally ambiguous actions and address a significant theme relatable to people of any time period. Because it contains morally ambiguous characters relatable to the audience and addresses the enduring ideas of courage, Harper Lee’s To Kill a Mockingbird should definitely be considered as a “timeless classic.”
What makes a novel a “timeless classic?” There are differing opinions on this topic. But having a significant theme is a criterion that often comes up, and interesting, well-rounded characters are also important. Theme and characterization are essential for any good book because they give the novel depth; a timeless classic should exceed in both these areas. To Kill a Mockingbird by Harper Lee should be considered a timeless classic; not only does it have an important, universal theme, but it also has round, compelling characters that effectively communicate the theme.
The tiny, sleepy, worn-out, dingy, slow-moving town of Maycomb, Alabama is where the novel takes place. The novel takes place in the early 1930s, during the Great Depression.
The modern phenomenon of shopping is closely linked to the emergence of the consumer society in the 18th century. Over the course of the two centuries from 1600 onwards, the purchasing power of the Englishman is average increase. In the first half of the 18th century, sugar consumption increase 100% and the different luxury goods, including tea and cotton a kept increase.
Many novels, despite having dissimilar plots, oftentimes contain similar story elements. Whether the similarity is the goal of the protagonist, or the motive of the antagonist, a similarity can be found between two novels. And even with the similarities, differences occur, which allow for comparison and contrast. And thus it is with Billy Budd by Herman Melville and The Scarlet Letter by Nathaniel Hawthorne. The two books are different concerning plot and setting, but they have similarities in the effect of the setting on the characters, the conflict between the protagonists and antagonists, and (third body paragraph?).
“The more you have to lose, the braver you are for standing up”, so say Charlie in Jasper Jones. This quote reflects both novels, as the both discuss the morally wrong actions due to racism or discrimination. To kill a mockingbird is so similar to Jasper Jones through its historical, ethical and social settings that critics are referring to Jasper Jones as an Australian version of To Kill a Mockingbird. These similarities are identified as we compare Jack Lionel and Boo Radley, Laura Wishart and Mayella Ewell and the small town life of both novels. The characters of both novels ma be very similar but the plot is much different.