Case One – Johnny Tenasco
Overview
In the case of Johnny Tenasco, it is evident to see how this client has fallen victim to the poor conditions that exist on many Canadian reserves. As mentioned in the case study, the client has endured familial abuse and addictions. The client has resorted to poor coping mechanisms through substance abuse in order to cope with his unresolved trauma, and this has lead him to develop unhealthy behaviours. The system has failed Johnny by not providing him with the necessary skills he needs in order to overcome his trauma and addictions. These coping mechanisms have lead Johnny to act out in public, which has lead into him having the current negative experience between him and the authorities.
Colonialism, Intergenerational Trauma and Substance Abuse Before we evaluate Johnny’s behaviour, it is important that we analyze the impacts of intergenerational trauma and how they have contributed to Johnny’s lack of well-being. Prior to colonialism, Indigenous Peoples withheld their own systems of governance, economy, trading, and furthermore. Before the arrival of Europeans, Indigenous Peoples were able to satisfy all of their material and spiritual needs through the resources that the land had provided for them. All Indigenous Peoples believed that their values and traditions were gifts from the Creator. One of the most important and most common teachings was that people should live in harmony with the natural world and all it contained. (Truth And Reconcilation Commission, 2015.) This respect for the land and all of its people was reflected through songs, dances, festivals and ceremonies. (Truth and Reconcilation Commission, 2015.) However following colonialism, all of these systems had been attacked and disrupted. While many Indigenous Peoples still continue to follow these traditions and practices, it is evident that so many of their existing systems had been destroyed and will not be the same as they once were. Next, we must analyze the conditions that exist on reserves and how they impact the Indigenous populations that inhabit them. In the year of 2016, 19.4% of Indigenous Peoples reported living on reserves that needed major repairs (Statistics Canada, 2016.) Many
Research indicates that colonial policies related to residential schools, reserve communities, loss of traditional lands, and erosion of language and cultural traditions that lead to cultural continuity have created a loss of cohesion and identity in Indigenous communities which have impacted family health behaviors (MacNeil 6). Although this may
Thomas King’s The Inconvenient Indian tells the story of Indigenous people in Canada and the United States, it challenges the narrative on how Indigenous history is taught and explains why Indigenous people continue to feel frustrated. King’s seeks to educate the reader as he provides a detailed accounts of the horrific massacres Indigenous people endured, yet he simultaneously inserts humorous moments which balances out the depressing content and enhances his story. The books highlights the neglect and assimilation that Indigenous were subjected to and how their survival was seen as an inconvenience to western culture. King directs his message at a Euro-centric audience to offer an accurate explanation of Indigenous culture and
The guest speaker Krystal Summers (2017) provided insight into the health and healing from an Indigenous worldview. This lecture presented me with the opportunity to enhance my understanding of the history and culture of Indigenous peoples in Canada through hearing Summers personal experiences. For social workers to be agents of change, they must seek to learn and understand Indigenous peoples cultural experiences and history with oppression (Mullaly, 2010). According to King, Smith, and Gracey (2009), they discovered that “indigenous health inequalities arise from general socioeconomic factors in combination with culturally and historically specific factors particular to the peoples affected” (p. 76). This point highlights one of the key ideas
This presents a clear picture of the sheer rapidity of the colonial project. It seems inevitable that much indigenous tradition and heritage will be swept away, resulting in feelings of profound cultural dislocation, and loss of identity.
Trauma can be defined as an “extreme, important event against a person’s body or self-concept” (Frideres, 2011, p. 80), and unless measures are taken to counteract the serious injury and harm caused by trauma it can result in the inability of a person to self-heal (Frideres, 2011). Trauma in Aboriginal people started happening over 500 years ago. This trauma is a result of cumulative emotional and psychological wounding resulting from massive group tragedies that have carried across generations (Wesley-Esquimaux &
Reservations have a major shortage of housing units, which has lead to three generations of family living together in one small house. "The effects this overcrowding has not just on the house itself but also on the mental and physical health of the people who live there, especially children" (Stastna, 2014). A lot of houses on the reservations are in dire need of fixing up. " 41.5 per cent of homes on reserves need major repairs, compared with seven per cent in non-aboriginal households outside reserves" (Stastna, 2014). Another factor is major health issues that aboriginals face on the reservations.
There is also an important recognition to be made between living conditions of those 26.6% of Aboriginal People’s living on reserves, and those 73.4% that are living off reserves (SOHC 34). The appalling inadequacies of the already limited on-reserve housing, such as lack of electricity, clean water, sanitation, safety, and extreme overcrowding force many to seek better lives in urban areas. Many, upon arrival, then have to face extreme discrimination via cultural oppression stemming from historical processes, economic causes and political neglect (Patrick 19). Through this naturalized racism stemming way into the colonial era, Aboriginal Peoples in these urban areas face obscene housing and economic discrimination (Patrick 22). This all results in Aboriginal Peoples in urban centers being 8 times more likely to experience homelessness than non-Aboriginals.
Colonialism has contributed to multiple issues in the lives of Aboriginal people including inadequate housing and clean resources on Aboriginal reserves. One significant outcome is health problems reserve residents face, including a lower life expectancy and higher mortality rate. “For Aboriginal men on reserve, life expectancy is 67.1 years, while off reserve it’s 72. 1, compared to 76 years for the general population of Canada. For Aboriginal women, it is 73.1, 77.7, and 81.5 respectively” (Frohlich et al. 134). Additionally, more than 50% of off reserve Aboriginal people have at least one chronic condition (Frohlich et al.). Reserves stem from the colonial era, where Aboriginal people were displaced by the government and are a continuous symbol of oppression.
The Department has a mandate to support Indigenous peoples in their pursuit of healthy and sustainable communities and broader economic and social development objectives. It provides funding for programs, services and initiatives to First Nations, Inuit and northern communities and governments, as well as to Indigenous and Metis organizations. The Departmental priorities are aligned with the issues that are most important to Indigenous peoples. The following are some of the more prominent issues facing First Nations in BC.
In 1958 Martin Luther King Jr. was quoted saying “Hate begets hate; violence begets violence”. Unfortunately for some, the violence and hate they receive begets violence and hate deep into themselves. For the Inuit people of northern Canada, racism presented through colonial violence and acculturation has caused a crippling affliction. The effect of this violence has manifested itself into various other forms of viciousness; domestic violence, substance abuse, neglect and self-harm are only a few. The perpetuation of this malicious cycle has created an exponential rise in violence against oneself. Additionally, the process of growing up and creating an identity is extremely difficult. Whereas, developing into an adult when faced with violence is exceptionally harder. Many young Inuit males succumb to this hardship. In comparison to the general population, adolescent Inuit males have a disproportionately high suicide rate. Through an intersectional analysis, I will examine the how racism caused by colonization, age, and gender have caused one of the highest suicide rates in the world.
There is a common belief that First Nations people have it easy: getting money from the government, free post-secondary education, and being exempt from certain taxes. Despite this, Aboriginals have much higher unemployment rates, lower life expectancies, and higher substance abuse rates (Bombay, Matheson, & Anisman, 2009, 7). As a result of colonization, First Nations’ resources were depleted, their land was stolen, and their cultures and identities were stripped from them. All of this was done in an attempt to civilize Aboriginal people; to assimilate them into white European culture. Very early on, settlers regarded Aboriginals as inferior to them and treated them accordingly. Children were taken from their families and forced into residential schools. Despite all of this, during the First World War many Aboriginal men volunteered to fight with the Canadian army. In Three Day Road, Joseph Boyden writes about the atrocities that residential school survivors endured not only in those schools, but fighting for the army in WWI. Boyden introduces three Cree characters: Elijah, Xavier, and Niska. Each one of these characters endured their own traumas and each chose their own ways to cope. Unfortunately, due to the extremely painful nature of both their physical and psychological wounds, these characters turn to different substances introduced to them by the settlers to cope. The effects from these traumas can be seen still in today’s generations of First Nations people.
Increasing empirical research supports this concept, and intergenerational effects in relation to various mental health outcomes have been observed in the adult offspring of Aboriginal adults in the US and Canada who were affected by forced relocations (Walls & Whitbeck, 2012) or by the forced removal of Indigenous children to residential schools for the purposes of assimilation (Bombay et al., 2014) (known as Indian Boarding Schools in the US). For example, it was shown that Aboriginal adults in Canada who had a parent or grandparent who attended Indian residential school were at greater risk for psychological distress and suicide attempts compared to those whose parents did not attend (McQuaid, Bombay, McInnis, Humeny, Matheson, & Anisman, 2017). Providing evidence for the cumulative nature of historical trauma events and experiences, it was also found that those with a parent and grandparent who attended – so with two previous familial generations who were directly affected - were at greater risk for these negative outcomes compared to those with only one previous generation who attended (i.e., parent or a grandparent) (McQuiad et al.,
The ultimate issues of Government social assistance in relation to Indigenous communities, is the fact that Provincial social assistance programs are temporary, promotes quick reintegration into the labour market, and persons who is receiving assistance must participate in employment programs in order to gain skills, education and experience needed reenter the labour market (cite). In remote Indigenous communities this is simply not a reality, 80% of Indigenous persons have been dependent on social assistance (cite). These issues occur since social service agencies are located off reserves, resulting in the lack the understanding of issues and social barriers faced by Fist Nation communities when interacting with service providers (cite).
Each individual makes up the society as it is, and various characteristics and beliefs makes up an individual. Although, individual lives together with a variety of personal ideologies, emotions, cultures, and rituals, they all differentiate one person from the other making up one’s own identity. This identity makes up who one is inside and out, their behaviour, actions, and words comes from their own practices and values. However, the profound history of Indigenous people raises question in the present about their identities. Who are they really? Do we as the non-native people judge them from the outside or the inside? Regardless of whether the society or the government were involved in their lives, they faced discrimination in every
We discussed how the narrative of dysfunction used to characterise Indigenous people and justify continued paternalistic colonial intervention. A narrative that conveniently ignores the conditions which led to the current situation, in which Indigenous communities display a high incidence of poverty and social dysfunction. Another quote I found on the forum states that “We (Canada) are the ones who have driven Indigenous peoples to have some of the highest numbers of incarceration, homelessness, substance abuse, high suicide rates” (Nestor, 2017). These conditions include the loss of land and sovereignty, generations of brutal violence and oppression, denial of access to sacred lands. Also, destruction of traditional economies and ways of life, and the legacy of forced assimilation, abuse and alienation from culture, language and history. All part of the genocidal war waged on Indigenous people by settler colonists.