preview

John Peter Zenger's Crimes

Decent Essays

In 1733, Governor Cosby attemped to rig an election in Westchester County. This resulted in opposition from the Popular Party, which included members such as James Alexander, Rip Van Dam and Lewis Morris. Cosby had illegaly removed Chief Justice Lewis Morris and replaced him with one of his supporters, James Delancey. Morris became the leader of the Popular Party. During the time, the only newspaper in New York was “The Gazette.” In order to raise opposition for Cosby and to expose his crimes, the Popular Party decided to print another newspaper. They were searching for a printer and found John Peter Zenger. Zenger was born in Germany, in 1697. At the age of 13, he was brought to New York by his parents and apprenticed to the best printer …show more content…

Whether the information was true or false did not matter. According to those times, "The greater the truth, the greater the libel." It was wrong to publish information against the government. Zenger did not deny printing the article and he was forced to go to jail because he refused to name the authors, who were anonymous. Zenger was in jail for nine months, waiting for his trial. During this time, his wife, Anna Catherine, continued to print The Journal. Zenger's lawyers were James Alexander and William Smith. Alexander was the editor of the Journal. The two lawyers challenged the right of Judge Delancey to preside over the trail. As a result, the Judge expelled both of the lawyers from their positions. Andrew Hamilton, the most famous lawyer in the colonies, became Zenger’s new attorney. The jury had to decide whether Zenger was the one who printed the Journal; and if he did print the stories, he was ordered to be convicted. Hamilton said that, “the jury had the right, if it chose to assert it, to decide both the law and facts.” Hamilton challenged the idea that truth is not a defense against libel. "If libel is understood in the unlimited sense urged by the attorney general, there is scarce a writing I know that may not be called a libel or scarce a person safe from being called to account as a libeler. Moses, meek as he was, libeled Cain- and who is it that not

Get Access