preview

John Bodley Argument

Decent Essays

Main Argument and Thesis The main point of the article is that oftentimes, the benefits of progress can be harmful to tribal peoples since these tribal peoples cannot control their resources or create a distinct relationship with the market. Supporting Evidence The author, John Bodley, supports the main argument through providing historical examples for each of the components of the argument. For example, after stating that economic progress can impact tribal peoples physically through increased disease infection, Bodley provides information about the Pukapuka and the Maori, as well as malnutrition status in Africa. These historical examples add merit to Bodley’s argument and strengthen the claims. Similarly, when exploring the detrimental effects that progress can have on the environment, Bodley uses research in Amazonia and information about the Shipibo Indians to support his argument. Through using historical examples to illustrate his claims, Bodley is able to build a more convincing argument. …show more content…

Often, an issue is that indicators used to measure benefits or disadvantages are not relevant in each culture. Bodley then introduces the concept that when self-sufficient tribal peoples are incorporated into the world economy, their standard of living is often lowered. Further, Bodley explains that economic advancement increases the number of people affected by diseases, like heart disease, diabetes, and high blood pressure. Following the discussion of physical health effects, Bodley discusses other detrimental impacts of progress, like environmental destruction, as well as the harmful widened gap between rich and poor. At the conclusion of the article, Bodley explains that in response to progress, social effects are also often present, including family life disruptions, rampant emotional conditions, and heightened

Get Access