preview

James Baldwin Definition Of Justice

Decent Essays

Though justice characterizes the founding documents of the United States and various religious doctrines, its definition remains elusive. The Merriam-Webster Dictionary initially struggles to present a cohesive explanation, referencing the establishment, administration, and determination of law, when law can be completely independent of justice. However, their third and final definition offers some substance — they write that justice is the “conformity to truth, fact, or reason.” This rendering of justice most clearly conveys the moral ideal that revolutionaries advocate for and governments seek to embody. In fact, it is through the legislation of this justice that it can become diluted, straying from conformity to truth and reason to conformity …show more content…

African American novelist James Baldwin wrote that to truly understand the administration of justice in society, “one goes to the unprotected — those, precisely, who need the law’s protection most! — and listens to their testimony.” In the United States those groups include citizens living under the poverty rate, minorities, and other communities overlooked by the government, and their stories often challenge the perception that American justice is administered evenly. For example, racial profiling destroys the protection of “innocent until proven guilty” for African-Americans, Muslims, and other groups, while justifying this blatant infringement of justice with the argument that it’s necessary for the increased safety of the nation. However, the unspoken truth reveals that this increased safety only applies to the white, privileged American citizens, while creating an assumed criminality for multiple American subcultures simply because of the color of their skin or the God they pray to. In addition, Michel Foucault professed that “justice must always question itself” in order to retain legitimacy, as an ever-questioned justice allows for constant evaluation and input from groups it is protecting or sometimes inadvertently harming, while a stagnant justice allows injustice to fester. Oftentimes, governments become hypocritical, raging against injustice when oppressed, and oppressing once they gain power. For example, during the American Revolution, patriots cursed the British government, adopting the slogan of “no taxation without representation” to express their outrage for legislation written an ocean away with no regard for their opinions. However, not even two centuries later, the American government remained deaf to African American pleas for enfranchisement, though they had identical complaints about legislation. Martin Luther

Get Access