preview

Jamaica Kincaid

Decent Essays

Elena Gonzalez
Hoggatt-Abader
Engl 101
September 29, 2015
The Demands of Womanhood Society plays a key role in determining how people are supposed to fulfill their roles in society—specifically their gender roles. This means that typically the norm is that men are to be the head of the house and are to be the financial supporters while women are typically categorized as being the homemaker and caretaker. The complexity and importance of being a woman the “right” way is shown through Jamaica Kincaid’s “Girl”, a short story reflecting her growing up in Antigua. “Girl” expresses all the in’s and out’s of being a good womanly figure and also illustrates how demanding and high pressure it is to get this role right. Through the repetitive use …show more content…

By using semi-colons it makes it seem as if all these rules all categorize together instead of making it seem as if certain rules fall under different categories. This can be shown in many instances in this story such as, “…this is how you iron your father’s khaki pants so that they don't have a crease; this is how you grow okra—far from the house”(200). Ironing and growing okra are far from being the same thing yet in this story it seems as if they are similar to each other. The use of semi-colons essentially groups all these rules into one category, that category being “Being a Good Woman”. By doing this, the author makes it seem like although not all these things are all housekeeping or cooking they all make up a bigger category which is one that is not just being a good housekeeper but being a good housekeeper as well as a cook, caretaker, and overall good woman. The semi-colons also show how Girl’s mother doesn't necessarily care what her daughter says all the time. There is a time in this story where Girl’s voice is shown through the use of italics briefly. By using semi-colons before and after Girl’s dialogue it shows how even though Girl might have said something, her mother is going to continue with what she was saying, “…but I don't sing benna on Sundays at all and never in Sunday school; this is how to sew on a button” (200). Girl tries to defend herself by telling her mother that she would never sing benna on Sundays, but instead of acknowledging it her mother continues with explaining how to sew buttons. By not ending the sentence after Girl’s dialogue it helps show how her mother is not going to stop explaining how to be a good woman to acknowledge her daughter trying to defend herself. This also shows how her mother does not necessarily care what her daughter has to say. Girl’s mother is less concerned

Get Access