preview

Is ADHD Evolution?

Better Essays

Is ADHD Evolution? ADHD (Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder) or ADD (Attention Deficit Disorder), a mental illness in which every American thinks they seem to have at times. Many people seem to think they have ‘ADHD brain’ or say they are ‘so ADHD’. ADHD or Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder is a mental disorder which is characterized by the DSM-V as impairing one's attention, shifting tasks constantly, and displaying hyperactive behavior (European consensus statement on diagnosis and treatment of Adult ADHD: The European Network Adult ADHD). Although some people seem to think ADHD is just something kids experience nowadays, recent research is showing perhaps ADHD is a product of natural selection, and at one time needed to survive …show more content…

In concerns to the hunter theory, Tremblay cites Thom Hartmann’s definition hunter theory in which states “ADHD might have actually stemmed from our ancestors to survive” (qtd. Shelby Tremblay). In this article, Tremblay writes “traits of distractibility, impulsiveness, and even aggression could have been beneficial to hunters. If a hunter quickly noticed something shining in the dark, the source of light was either potential prey or a potential predator”. Given Nomadic hunters depend heavily on hunting as a source for food, these benefits would have definitely helped a person in Nomadic settings and would have given tribesmen afflicted with ADHD, an evolutionary advantage. This might also help explain why Eisenberg found a higher prevalence of the allele expression 7-DRD4 in nomadic tribesmen given 7-DR4D is associated with ADHD. In the fighter theory section of her research article, Tremblay notes the extinction of the Homo Neanderthals as evidence that becoming a fighter was an advantage for early human civilization. According to Tremblay, she states that the extinction of the Neanderthals was caused by either having a slightly reproduction rate, or by initiating aggression on the Neanderthals as they were in direct competition with Homo Sapiens for …show more content…

Dr. Thomas Barkley provides a counter argument about why ADHD is not human evolution. In an interview conducted on him by Thom Hartmann about whether or not ADHD is evolutionary. Dr. Thomas Barkley proposes that we do not know enough about ADHD to conclude that ADHD is a product of human evolution. Dr. Barkley states that just because people afflicted with ADHD can be successful you cannot correlate ADHD with success. Barkley states “Ulysses S. Grant was a great general because he drank” (ADHD Disorder or Difference). In his interview Dr. Thomas Barkley fails to state any scientific evidence to back his claims up. To defend his argument, Dr. Thomas Barkley states we do not know enough about psychology to firmly state ADHD is a result of evolution and when we know enough about ADHD, we will be able to state that ADHD is not caused by Human evolution. Thomas Barkley does not disprove any articles or studies of psychologists such as Elaine Morgan’s Descent of women, he merely states that we do not know enough about Psychology to say ADHD isn’t

Get Access