preview

Irene Winter's Thesis

Decent Essays

2.1. What is Irene Winter’s thesis or main argument?
The main argument is about the problem posed for the modern viewer by the eroticized body of the political ruler, which wasn't a problem for the ancient - Mesopotamians; that sexuality was inextricably linked to potency to male vigor and manly vigor to dominance and authority. In other words, Irene Winter's thesis is about sexuality signifying rule in ancient times.

2.2. What attributes does Narim-Sin possess that make him appear to be a ruler?
Neck-beard: signifying protection
He stands in the way such that he's right body is perfectly visible
Narim-Sin’s beard, breadth of chest and virile stance
Beautifully-proportioned body and lithe along with his griddle tied seductively over his …show more content…

Describe how Narim-Sin’s physical appearance is different from Eannatum’s
Eannatum is identified by the name and wrapped in a distinctive garment, but otherwise barely distinguished physically from the phalanx that he leads into the battle
Though power is inherent in the solid proportions of the body, the full developed revealed body of narim-Sin is missing

2.4. Identify Narim-Sin’s divine attributes.
The helmet was worn by Narim sin on the steal- one with bullhorns: as the headgear is reserved for GODS
Determinatives for Gods used prefixes like the one - ‘God of Agade.'
His divine body - the vitality of his perfect and alluring body

2.5. Where was this stele originally located?
Since stele was carried off as booty to Elam in the 12th-century B.C.E, we cannot know the exactly where it was placed originally; however, circumstantial evidence suggests that it was posited in the temple of the sun god Shamash at Sippar

2.6. How would male and female viewers in the ancient Near East respond to this …show more content…

The purpose of such votive statuary placed in temples was to urge the donors might to remain in a state of everlasting prayer. For example, The relief scene beneath Ur-Ningirsu’s bare feet, of kneeling men bearing full baskets, may represent bearers of ritual offerings.

3.2 Describe the head of Ur-Ningirsu and identify similarities with representations of his father Gudea (as noted in the article and based on your observations).
Head of Ur-Ningirsu:
Head of Ur-Ningirsu is beardless and large, rather cubic-shaped that sits on shoulders without much of a neck.
It has large, heavy-lidded eyes.
The curving eyebrows meet on the bridge of the nose and are accentuated by incised lines in a herringbone pattern.
It also has a prominent nose, a closed mouth with nicely shaped lips
The strong jaw is very similar to that seen on the rare intact statues of his father, Gudea, portraying an actual physiognomic family trait.

3.3 Describe the challenges in trying to bring together the head of Ur-Ningirsu at the Metropolitan Museum in New York and the body of Ur-Ningirsu at the Musee du Louvre in

Get Access