preview

Informative Essay On The Lottery By Madeleine Sackler

Decent Essays

The documentary, “The Lottery” by Madeleine Sackler, is about a neighborhood in New York City called Harlem. Harlem is populated by a majority of low-income African-American residents. The documentary tries to inform us about how hard it is to get good education in a poor community like this one and how crucial it is for low-income parents to make it happen through a lottery in the Harlem Success Academy Charter School. Is this documentary an effective argument? An effective argument should be informative, persuasive, should have strong appeal, and strong evidence. Yes, I believe that this documentary is an effective argument because it has all the qualities required for an effective argument. To be informative means to impart knowledge or to educate (Merriam Webster Dictionary). This documentary is informative because it states the issues clearly and gives us good background information about the community and the oppositions against charter schools, specifically the Harlem Success Academy. Teachers’ Union thinks that charter schools are a threat to public schools because they are stealing their students and are splitting up their community into two. Also, the only way for students to enter into the …show more content…

Logical appeals should have credible expert interviews, statistics, observations, and acknowledgment of the opposition (University Writing Center). The Lottery is credible by interviewing experts as in the president/CEO of Harlem Children’s Zone- Geoffrey Canada, the Mayor of Newark- Cory Brooker, and the Founder/CEO of Success Academy of Charter Schools- Eva Moskowitz. The statistics show that 58% of fourth graders are functionally illiterate and that black 12th graders are equivalent to white 8th graders (Sackler, 2010). It shows the observations of both sides of the story (the Harlem Success vs the teachers’ union) and the struggle of the parents preparing their children at home for the lottery

Get Access