preview

In The Penal Colony

Better Essays

The systematic incarceration and imprisonment of “delinquents” are often veiled within the rhetoric of law, deeming that such processes are monolithic and truly uphold to just standards. However, the prison industrial complex relies solely on the “othering” of marginalized communities, ultimately leaving these communities voiceless and powerless. Throughout Franz Kafka’s short story, “In the Penal Colony,” he vividly addresses the violence and performativity within an outlandish justice system. Kafka’s social critique examines how contemporary justice systems exploit the voiceless in an attempt to bring a false promise of justice. In the same vein, Frantz Fanon’s The Fact of Blackness and Patricia Williams “The Alchemy of Race and Rights,” …show more content…

He expands on the punishment to the Traveller, stating that “The law which a condemned man has violated is inscribed on his body with the Harrow. . . [inscribing] on his body, ‘Honour your superiors’” (Kafka 5). Although Kafka uses a dystopic framework to describe the justice system, it neatly interlocks with the “contemporary” framework of the U.S. prison industrial complex. Kafka elicits the ambiguity surrounding justice and the obsession of reforming a subject through law, implying that there should be a transformative aspect in justice systems. Accordingly, the physical inscribing of law onto the Condemned man’s back is reminiscent to how prison systems attempt to reinscribe proper social values into prisoners. Prisons aim to mentally and psychologically “repair” the minds of the prisoners, although not as physical as a tattoo, it still focuses on the mentality of purifying the subject. This focus on moral improvement, then, reveals the truth behind both Kafka’s dystopic colony and contemporary modes of justice: to systematically punish deviants to work in accordance with dominant structures. Thus, the violent focus on the body and the mind demonstrates how systems of justice operate on violence in an attempt to regulate and reform the structures of

Get Access