In Her Life Sir She Have Never Lie Analysis

“Whatever you do, it is a good man who does it.” This quote was said by Elizabeth Proctor, a character in The Crucible. Here Elizabeth is saying that her husband is a good man which shows that she has finally forgiven him for the affair he had earlier in the play. Elizabeth Proctor is a good Christian woman who is very honest. She is married to John Proctor but keeps a cold house ever since John had the affair with Abigail Williams. Elizabeth is accused of witchcraft when Abigail is stabbed in the stomach and they then find a poppet with a needle in it belonging to Elizabeth. I consider myself to have similar characteristics with Elizabeth Proctor because we are both caring, forgiving, and honest.

Elizabeth Proctor is an honest and virtuous christian woman from Salem. Abigail being the pretentious girl from the village accuses her of witchcraft causing, Elizabeth to be in prison. While Elizabeth is in prison her husband, John Proctor admits to lechery with Abigail. Elizabeth shows her loyalty towards John by lying in court to protect him (Miller 46). Although the affair hurt Elizabeth, there is still a devotion towards her husband.

Elizabeth Proctor and I “If you think I am one, then I say there are none”, this quote was said by Elizabeth Proctor. Elizabeth said this when she was accused of witchcraft during the Salem Witch Trials. Although Elizabeth was accused of witchcraft she was not hung. Elizabeth and I have very similar personality traits such as honest, unforgiving, and loyal.

In 1692, nineteen innocent people were convicted and hanged for witchcraft. In Arthur Miller’s, The Crucible, most characters are unable to change because of their religion or other beliefs. However, three people change drastically for the better. Elizabeth Proctor does something she has never done before in order to save someone she loves. Reverend Hale moves past his religious beliefs in attempts to save those accused of witchcraft.

She admits to dismissing Abigail as her servant but she refuses to admit to Proctor’s affair. However, she admits that their relationship was the strongest and that he fancied Abigail. Dantforth states, “… Is your husband a lecher!” (Miller 113). Elizabeth responds, “No sir” (Miller 113). The reader knows Elizabeth is lying as in Act one and two she confronted Proctor about his affair. She lies to protect his reputation, although she still has not forgiven him completely. Her lie is ironic because her husband has already confessed to the affair and using his affair to prove Abigail is motivated by vegence. However, when Elizabeth denies the affair she attempts to save his reputation but indeed damages his reputation by making it look like Proctor is lying to the

Elizabeth Proctor might be portrayed as only inverse of Abigail. A dependable wife of John Proctor, Elizabeth demonstrated to her group proper methodologies to be more than an observer in life. John thought of her the sweetest, most sure, and legit lady he has ever met. The point when deciding his hanging, John offered Elizabeth to discuss an occurrence that as of late happened on the grounds that he knew she might tell the complete truth, regardless of the possibility that his life was at stake. He said to the judges "Throughout her life sir, she will never lie" (Miller, Act 3). Despite the fact that Proctor submitted infidelity, Elizabeth chipped away at pardoning him due to her kind and religious heart. She never surrendered attempting to get John to concentrate on her again. For instance, she says "You'll tear it free- when you come to realize that I will be your just wife, or no wife whatsoever. She has a shaft in you yet, John Proctor, and you know it well!" (Miller, Act 2).

Throughout the entire play of The Crucible, John Proctor truly grew as a person, while later fixing his sins and making moral decisions. John Proctor had truly gone through a lot in the play, both emotionally and physically, being that he was wrongfully accused of witchcraft. Although some might contradict this statement, John Proctor loved his wife, Elizabeth, because even though he may have questioned her worth in the past, he always confesses his sins and does what he can to make it right, which is a true quality of a man. Along with this, John Proctor portrays characteristics of a Puritan because he always remains true to his family, alike he must stay true to God, therefore proving to him that John Proctor always stays true.

John Proctor sought his wife’s forgiveness to regain her trust and to entitle him to die an honest man. He recognized his actions; he simply wanted his wife to recognize them too. “Let you look sometimes for the goodness in me, and judge me not.” (Miller 55) Proctor’s appeal to his wife reveals his hope for her forgiveness and for her to see the goodness in him. He wants his wife to recognize him as an honest man, because to him that is the only substance that made him feel like a good person. Later in the course of the play, Elizabeth forgives Proctor for his mistakes. She states, “John, it come to naught that I should forgive you… Whatever you will do, it is a good man does it… it needs a cold wife to prompt lechery.” (Miller 136-137) Elizabeth’s statement to her husband exhibits an understanding of his mistakes and acknowledgement of the good man Proctor truly is. Elizabeth’s forgiveness allows Proctor to forgive himself as well. After being forgiven, John Proctor can now die an honest man, a tragic hero - a man with integrity and goodness.

During this time in Salem, Massachusetts woman were being accused of witchcraft and if they did not confess to witchcraft, they found guilty and were hanged. Elizabeth Proctor was among the many women accused and despite all the women who confessed false testimonies, she was among the few who did not want to tell a lie to save her life. “Do why you will. But let none be your judge. There be no higher judge under Heaven than Proctor is! Forgive me, forgive me, John- I never knew such goodness in the world!” At this point in The Crucible, Elizabeth is good with herself and with her beliefs. She refuses to confess to something that she is not guilty of. Women were mostly targeted because they were viewed as the minority in Salem and easy to manipulate but not Elizabeth Proctor she stood firm in her

John Proctor tried his hardest and went through hell and gave his life to try to save the people of his town in Salem. “ I am only wondering how i may prove what she told me Elizabeth. If the girl's a saint now; I think it not easy to prove she's a fraud the town gone silly., she told me in a room alone, I have no proof for it” (2.127-131). My explanation is by him saying that he means its going to be hard to prove Elizabeth Proctor is guilty and they are going to find out it's a lie. I connected to this because John and his wife are innocent and she never tells a lie, also they can't even prove that they are lying even if they were. Joth talked to Hale about the situation when Hale came to John's home in the middle of the night to ask questions.

Within the community of Salem, John Proctor is a well known member of the community who has a reputation of always doing what’s right. When he is confronted by Abigail about their affair, she insults his wife, Elizabeth, by calling her “a cold, sniveling woman…”(I.202-205). He does what is right by defending his wife’s honor by snapping back, “You’ll speak nothin’ of Elizabeth!” (I.197-198). Even

Although John Proctor and Abigail Williams are dishonest throughout the majority of The Crucible, Elizabeth Proctor remains truthful for most of the story. She does make one very grave mistake that sets the precedent for her husband’s future. When asked, “To your own knowledge,

John Proctor vouching for the purity of Elizabeth’s word John stating, “In her Life sir, she have never lied. There are them that cannot sing, and them that cannot weep-- my wife cannot lie. I have paid much to learn it, sir?” However, Elizabeth trying to protect his husband saying a very common lie; that lie condemning John to getting jailed. Elizabeth Proctor stating, “No sir,” trying to save her husband’s reputation defending John with the stance of he did not commit lechery the one lie she said being the ultimate cause of John to get hanged, due to blackening his name. Judge Danforth not believing John and him admitting to the crime of lechery, John tarnishing his name in hopes of condemning

John Proctor regrets of breaking his marriage vows, now his wife Elizabeth is being accused of witchcraft by Abigail Williams. Based on the statement by

Elizabeth Proctor is honest throughout The Crucible. She influenced others to be honest as well. Since people throughout Salem are not telling the