preview

Humanitarian Aftershocks In Haiti Summary

Decent Essays

On January 12, 2010 on of the world’s deadliest earthquakes struck Haiti. In his book, Humanitarian Aftershocks in Haiti, Mark Schuller analyzes the presence of humanitarian aid agencies following the disaster. He discusses the impacts the aid had on the environment, development and globalization of Haiti. Chapter 6 is titled, “Aba ONG vole”—down with the NGO thieves—a common phrase following the emergence of humanitarian agencies in Haiti. As one may expect a majority of the Haitian population was found to have negative impressions of the NGOs, however it is interesting to note that it was reported that a third of the Haitians questioned felt they did not have a sufficient amount of information to form an impression of the NGOs. In fact, there where even debates as to whether or whether not institutes were to be …show more content…

Humanitarians claim that their lack of success in Haiti in a result of Haiti being both a “failed state” and an urban disaster, as well as the fact that there was poor coordination. It seems that the main cause of the poor coordination was that it was difficult to distinguish whether an individual had been affected by the disaster, this made it difficult to make a distinction between humanitarian aid and development. According to Schuller the core difference in the ideology of development and that if humanitarian aid is that the first is "doing for" while the latter is "working with beneficiary communities" (208). Schuller emphasizes that humanitarian aid is culturally specific. I found this statement interesting, I would have assumed that humanitarian aid is universal and capable of functioning in all cultures. Schuller’s statement also leads to the question or whether the humanitarian aid was incapable of producing favorable results because Haiti needed to be developed before the country was capable of utilizing humanitarian

Get Access