preview

Howie And Laura's Excursion: Justifiable Or Justified?

Decent Essays

One important reason that Howie and Laura's excursion was not justifiable and was foolish and they should be punished for their actions is that Howie and Laura face trouble everywhere they go. When Howie and Laura arrive at the Dining Hall, Howie begins to be angered by Pardo."The boy kicked him hard in the side of the knee. Pardoe made a loud, ugly sound and fell down on the floor." (Page 85). What this means is Howie and Laura face trouble when Howie ended up in a fight with Pardoe. Howie and Laura also end up making a commotion in the Dining Hall. The other side of the argument is Howie and Laura have been helped by many people along their journey. But the argument that Howie and Laura face trouble everywhere they go is still true. The key …show more content…

During their time on the municipal beach, Howie and Laura end up stealing clothing, baskets."If you kept him busy I could grab a couple of baskets.”(Page 42). The point is Howie and Laura faced a situation where they had many choices but chose to steal. Although they had needed new clothing, it is still not justifiable for stealing other’s clothing, which explains how the evidence proves the claim. Of course, it is possible to disagree with the view that Howie and Laura could have been arrested for stealing and instead argue that Howie and Laura needed to steal to survive. However, stronger evidence is on the other side. What must be remembered is that Howie and Laura would not need to steal if they had gone back to the camp. This is essentially why Howie and Laura could have been arrested for stealing. Howie and Laura had many options when it came to leaving the cabin, they could have waited to be brought back to the camp but they chose to run away. Howie and Laura’s actions are not justifiable just because they are

Get Access