preview

How Does O Brien Bear The Burden Of Guilt

Decent Essays

Christian Bandoo McGee 7 th 3/4/2024 English II AAC The Man I Killed "The Man I Killed" In Tim O'Brien's narrative, "The Man I Killed," found in his book “The Things They Carried”, the depiction of a young Vietnamese soldier's death causes reflections on war, morality, and responsibility. I affirm that Tim O'Brien should not bear the burden of guilt or shame for the soldier’s death. Instead, the blame rests on the grotesque nature of war, survival of the fittest, and dehumanizing nature placed on soldiers. Looking at the graphic details, such as "His jaw was in his throat, his upper lip and teeth were gone, his one eye was a star-shaped hole," (O’Brien 118), gives the reader a foundation for the argument. This graphic portrayal highlights …show more content…

For example, when O’Brien described that "His jaw was in his throat," (O’Brien 118) it emphasized the shared humanity between soldiers. This perspective challenges individual guilt by showing how war affects people's minds in a widespread way. In addition, the passage reveals that the young man was not naturally inclined for combat as "[The young soldier] was not a fighter. His health was poor, his body small and frail." (O’Brien 119) This contrast shows the instinct for self-preservation, portraying O'Brien's actions as a response to the unavoidable cruelty of warfare. Evidence, like the soldier's frail physique, strengthens the argument that O'Brien's actions were driven by survival rather than malice. Furthermore, raised in a village with a tradition of patriotic resistance, the young man had little power in resisting the call to arms since "He had accepted this. It was never open to question," (O’Brien 119). This highlights the societal expectations that guided the soldier's path. This shifts blame from the individual to systemic issues that push him into a conflict he was not looking

Get Access