In Julius Caesar, you are faced with a lot of dilemmas, lies, and betrayals, but of the betrayals was Brutus' one of them? Did Brutus betray a friend or was he a Patriot to his people? All of it comes down to intent, did Brutus do it out of hate and blood lust or did he do it out of sorrow and for a better future? The fact is that Brutus did it knowing it was wrong but also knowing that it would make Rome a better and safer place for the people he loved so dearly.
Some may call Brutus a betrayer just do to the fact that he joined the conspiracy, but it was the way he joined that says a lot about his character. Originally when Cassius asked Brutus to join him and the conspiracy Brutus turned him down and said that killing Cesar would be too harsh. Cassius was trying to kill Caesar out of hate and jealousy but fooled Brutus into thinking it was for the good of Rome. Cassius had Cinna put notes in Brutus’ chair, on Brutus’ window, and also on the statues of Brutus’ ancestors. After reading the notes Brutus is convinced that Caesar must be killed because he wants to be crowned, and if Caesar is crowned he will have the power to do bad things to the Roman people and he can’t
…show more content…
When the deed of killing Caesar is being done Brutus takes the last stab and Caesar is surprised, but in that moment you could tell that Brutus didn’t want to do it but he had too. After all of this things spiral out of control and war breaks out which isn’t what Brutus wanted he wanted people to be safe not for them to be scared of war, so after a few battles Brutus has someone hold a sword as he runs on it. When Brutus kills himself that just adds to the list of things he has done for his people and shows how much he loves the Roman people. Now I ask the same question, is Brutus a betrayer or is he a
He compares Caesar to a serpent in an egg which he must kill before it hatches. Brutus knows that Caesar is gaining too much power too quickly and it must come to an end. He shows his belief in a republic government by saying, “We all stand up against the spirit of Caesar / And in the spirit of men there is no blood" (II.i. 180-181). Cassius is a character who is jealous of Caesar’s power and also wants it to end. He forms a group of conspirators who are against Julius Caesar. He persuades Brutus to help him and the other conspirators to kill Caesar during the ides of March. Brutus joins but only due to his love for Rome and its people. He proves this by saying "Let us be sacrificers, but not butchers, Caius." (II.i. 179). This also proves his love for Caesar because he wants to kill him with some sort of honor. Brutus wants the citizens to look at him not as a murderer but for someone who cares for his country. He expresses his ideas toward the stabbing by saying , “If then that friend demand why Brutus rose against Caesar, this is my answer-not that I loved Caesar less, but that I loved Rome more" (III, ii, 17-19).
I think that Brutus was a betrayer although others may think he is both. He is a patriot and he adored Rome so much to the point he wanted to protect it and defend it. At the same time, I think he was a traitor because he killed Caesar. Brutus was trying to get all the townspeople to believe that he is amazing and a noble person. Caesar came and saw Brutus and Brutus stabbed his own friend. He betrayed Caesar even though they were good friends before.
Indeed, Brutus was a honorable man. His honor was his greatest strength, but it was also his weakness. He murdered and betrayed his closest and only friend, due to the fact that he was so focused on doing the most honorable thing. Brutus focused more on principles, than the one person who truly cared about him. Consequently he also cared more about principle, than his own common sense. Therefore, his main focus was on honor and principle, which caused him to kill Caesar. He murdered Caesar because he thought it would solve the problem, but it only caused pandemonium.Consequently, his actions produced an angry mob, ready to avenge Caesar's death. If Brutus never took matters into his own hands, he would not have created a vicious crowd of citizens filled with hatred. He never solved the problem. When it got out of control, he resorted to killing himself. Cowardly, when things got tough, he ran away from it. He
Brutus definitely does not show how he is a honorable and loyal person. He focused too much about what he thoughts best for Rome and less about the people. During the play, Brutus also betrayed his wife, Portia. Portia notices something is up with Brutus. When Portia brings it up to Brutus, he will not tell her his plans to murder Caesar. Portia states, “If this were true, then I should know this secret. I grant I am a woman, but withal A woman that Lord Brutus took to wife.” (2.1.290-293). Brutus betrayed Portia by refusing to tell her the secret she begged to hear. She eventually stabs herself, and
Would you kill your best friend because you thought it was the only way to save your country? Such an extreme situation exists in Shakespeare’s play, Julius Caesar. To protect the future of his republic, Brutus kills Caesar, which leads to the big takeaway question: Is Brutus a patriot or a betrayer? Some people may believe that Brutus is a betrayer because he stabbed his friend in the back. However, Brutus did what most people don’t have the courage to do; he stood up for what he believed in and acted upon it; most people would just wish they did something. Brutus’s love for his country compelled him to protect its future from Caesar’s ambition. As a result, he did what he thought was right in order to protect his country. Brutus’s actions define his role as a patriot.
Brutus is one of Julius Caesar’s best friends and is viewed as either a patriot or betrayer. Brutus takes Caesar’s life claiming that it’s for the benefit of Rome just as Caesar is about obtain the Roman Empire essentially. I view Brutus as a betrayer and nothing more than a murderer because of his actions and the blood of Julius Caesar that is undoubtedly staining his hands. Some might disagree and claim him to be a patriot because he fought for what Rome really needed and saved them from Caesar’s rule that would only worsen Rome’s situation and the daily lives of the Roman citizens. Brutus fought for what he believed in that is undeniable, but it’s up to you and me to decide whether or not those beliefs made him into a betrayer or patriot.
In the end, Brutus was both a patriot and a betrayer. While he did kill for Rome, he betrayed his friend. I slew my best lover.” He did, and spoke this, because he was focusing on his own selfish fears. Through it all, he did what he truly believed what was best for Rome, even if that means killing his friend. He even offered his own life to Rome “shall please my country to need my death.” Despite the sin he committed, Brutus was a patriot for Rome. He killed the serpent that terrified him and threatened his people, all for his beloved country. Only a true patriot could make such
Brutus was very naive and got influenced by Cassius very easily. Cassius was very smart and manipulated Brutus to make him agree with him. Cassius said, “If I were Brutus now, and he were Cassius, He should not humour me.” (Shakespeare, p.13). Brutus believed that his friend, Caesar had a negative impact on Rome decided to join the conspiracy to assassinate Caesar. Even though Caesar was his friend, Brutus always showed loyalty towards Rome. Brutus' tragic flaw is that he is not good at figuring out other’s intentions, and trusted Cassius. If Brutus never listened to Cassius in the first place, he would not have joined the conspiracy, and might not have had a tragic end.
Brutus is truly “an honorable man.” He was initially resistant to Cassius’ suggestion to betray Caesar. Also, Brutus says, “not that I loved Caesar less, but that I loved Rome more.”(3.2.22) This proves that he only does what he feels is necessary to protect the Rome. In act 4, Brutus sees the ghost of Caesar, and this tells us that he is regretting his actions. He never felt right about killing Caesar afterwards. In fact, when he realized that he was wrong, he used the knife that he stabbed Caesar to take his own
Brutus believes he must put his own personal self and relationships behind for the betterment of Rome, leading to the people turning against him. One of the first examples is when he was brought the concept of killing Caesar, after much thought and deliberation he decides he must put away his own relationships for the betterment of his country. “O conspiracy, Sham'st thou to show thy dangerous brow by night, When evils are most free? O, then, by day Where wilt thou find a cavern dark enough To mask thy monstrous visage? Seek none, conspiracy. Hide it in smiles and affability; For if thou path, thy native semblance on, Not Erebus itself were dim enough To hide thee from prevention.” (2.1.84-93) He knows that by doing this act he will inflict consequences of a great degree upon himself, but he knows he must do it for the betterment of Rome. He then
Brutus was in fact a betrayer, and while he did feel sympathy for Caesar after he died, he killed him along with the other conspirators and even started a war of sorts in Rome, causing many to fall in battle- himself included. While Brutus was persuaded by fake letters, no man should be as gullible as him to completely switch sides on only the basis of three anonymous letters that were stuck to his window. Brutus was a villain who felt that he was the hero, more concerned about the safety of the government he loved rather than the friend that he loved.
Brutus explains that Caesar was no less to him than his country, but Brutus takes hatred letters into consideration (from the “plebeians”), he is also convinced by Cassius to kill Caesar for the good of Rome. Although Brutus was hesitant, he did end up doing it for his country and no other bad intentions. “If then that friend demand why Brutus rose against Caesar, this is my answer: not that I loved Caesar less, but that I loved Rome more.” (pg.831). In my opinion, i feel his sense of patriotism justifies his decision to kill his own successful friend. Throughout the play, Brutus knew that once Antony turned plebeians against all conspirators with his speech, there would be a major conflict between conspirators and all other decisions made. Towards the end of the battle between Brutus' forces and Antony's’ forces, Brutus knows he isn't in a good state and finally realizes he has to take his own life for his country. “With this depart, that, as I slew my best lover for the good of Rome, i have the same dagger for myself, when it shall please my country to need my death.” (pg. ) I believe that Brutus is saying, just as he was willing to kill his best friend, in cold blood, to save Rome from such a leader, he will just as readily turn the same dagger on himself if it benefits his
Brutus was very loyal to Rome, especially because one of his ancestors “would have brooked th’ eternal devil to keep his state in Rome as easily as a king” (I,ii,159-161). Lucius Junius Brutus had a role in establishing the Republic of Rome after expelling the last king of Rome, which put pressure on Brutus to maintain his family’s honor. Although Caesar was his best friend, Brutus became concerned after multiple people had informed him of Caesar’s questionable actions which were considered ambitious. Convinced, Brutus joined the plan to kill Caesar after he became more aware of Caesar’s actions.
Do you think that Brutus is a betrayer or a patriot? I think he was both but if I had to pick I would say he was a betrayer. I think he was a betrayer because he killed his best friend for the good of Rome but it wasn’t a good thing. Brutus was a betrayer because he wanted to kill Caesar just so he could take his place. He was a betrayer because he killed his best friend instead of thinking of another way to stop him. Brutus was finally convinced to kill Caesar when Cassius planted fake letters from Rome inside Brutus’s room that said they would prefer if Caesar was indeed killed.
In “The Tragedy of Julius Caesar”, Brutus was a villain. He was a man who loved Caesar and was a friend of Caesar’s throughout the play leading to his death. Throughout the play, Brutus fell for the manipulative ways of Cassius and the other conspirators. Brutus made several mistakes along with being a bad person in the play. He had several faults which involved him killing one of his closest friends one of the first acts of the play. There were some ways that Brutus is a good person, but those ways are hard to find over the bad choices he made over the course of the play.