preview

How Are Junior And Thomas Alike

Decent Essays

Compare and Contrast Essay Imagine being caught between two different worlds. In Sherman Alexie’s book The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian and the movie Smoke Signals, also by Sherman Alexie, the main characters experience a world that is very different from the reservation they grew up on. Both stories explore life on the rez and life outside of the rez in the United States through the characters and the plots that have several similarities and differences. In both stories, Alexie creates characters that are very similar to each other. In the book, Junior is introduced. He is Native American, wears glasses, loves family members, and is creative. Likewise, Thomas from the movie also has these traits and similar experiences. Nevertheless, …show more content…

In addition to Junior and Thomas, the characters Rowdy and Victor are also similar and different. Both Rowdy and Victor are Native American, play basketball, have anger issues, punch their friends, and have alcoholic fathers who abuse them. However, Rowdy is a freshman in high school and his father did not abandon his family and is still alive. In contrast, Victor is a senior high school or older, and his father, Arnold Joseph, abandoned him and his mother when he was about 12 years old, and Arnold eventually died without ever having returned. Moreover, both Rowdy and Victor are angry due to the treatment they received from their fathers, but Victor learns to forgive his dad unlike Rowdy who does not seem to have any resolution to his bad feelings. As a result, Rowdy from TATDoaPTI and Victor from Smoke Signals appear to parallel each other in many ways. Although the similarities among the characters in both stories is important, the most notable comparison can be found in the plot details. In the book and the movie, Alexie tells the story of Native Americans who leave their Indian reservations to go on a journey, though the reasons for their departures are …show more content…

Both Junior and Victor encounter racism and hardships on their journeys that eventually lead them to personal growth and understanding about themselves. Unlike Junior who learns to believe in himself and his intelligence, Victor learns to forgive his father and heals emotionally when he realizes that his dad never meant to leave or wanted to leave him and his mother. Despite the plots of these stories having clear and obvious differences, the similarities are undeniable. Overall, through The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian and Smoke Signals, Sherman Alexie created powerful tales about life on an Indian reservation and the hardships the main characters face. Junior and Thomas parallel one another in several ways such as their appearance and personality, and Rowdy and Victor are also similar in these same ways. Not only that, but the plots also focus on several of these characters leaving their reservations; however, the circumstances surrounding their departures are different, for Junior is seeking a better education and life, while Victor is seeking to collect his deceased father and find closure to his

Get Access