preview

Hospital Asthma Care

Decent Essays

Often in the well-developed country of New Zealand, citizens face difficult decisions regarding their health care choices. Rosie, is one such citizen, who’s moderate symptoms of asthma have led to a dilemma. Rosie knows that she requires treatment however, is uncertain of whether she should visit a local general practitioner, or an emergency department. This quandary has occurred due to the fact that she is a student and is financially unstable, having only $150 a week after paying her accommodation. Whereas the GP will cost her a total of $33, the emergency department will have no co-payment for its service. The essay will examine the various advantages and disadvantages of each option, and will then go on to analyse the implications on the …show more content…

First of all, Rosie will be provided treatment with better quality. A hospital is more likely to provide expert care due to the number of specialists present. An emergency department would offer clinical quality as accessibility to diagnosis and clinical practices will be present immediately. Bodenheimer, T. S., and Grumbach, K. (2009) argue that direct access by Rosie to an ED is a less unified model of care, however, it may allow access to specialists with better experience at managing her individual condition of asthma. According to Health Evidence Network (2004), advance resource allocation in most countries, including NZ, still favours hospitals. In a study conducted by Jollis et al, (1996), (as cited by Health Evidence Network, 2004), it was discovered that specialists perform better than generalists when managing certain conditions. According to another study conducted by Schoen, C., et al. (2004), 51% of New Zealander’s surveyed rated the emergency care services as excellent or very good. Secondly, Rosie would have a cost advantage, as there is no co-payment and she will be covered by the general health care. Hospitals manage highly complex and specialized impatient health care needs, therefore if Rosie visits an ED, she will be receiving quality treatment for free. Jantrana, S. & Crampton, P. (2009) had noticed in their study that even those patients who were enrolled with a GP, seeked care in hospital emergency departments because of

Get Access