preview

Holden Caulfield Relationships

Better Essays

Likewise, after the third school, Pencey Preparatory school in Pennsylvania expels Holden, the first thing he misses are the friends he made. In the rural area of California, he recollects about his friends at the end of his autobiography, he says, “About all I know is, I sort of miss everybody… Even old Stradlater and Ackley”(214). At Pencey Preparatory School, Holden always criticizes everyone, even his friends, Stradlater and Ackley. He calls them, “dirty”(19) and “morons”(52). Before leaving Pencey preparatory school, he fights Stradlater and disturbs Ackley’s sleep multiple times. He is definitely not in good terms with them; yet, he misses them after leaving Pencey Preparatory school. His terrible treatment of his friends is contradictory …show more content…

Moreover, the setting reinforces this idea, where even after his treacherous journey throughout the story: three schools expel him and takes a trip halfway across the country from Pennsylvania to California; what Holden yearns the most is the company of friends, he misses the security that friendship can give. Only without friendship, he begins to understand the benefits that friendship can give him. In comparison to Jim, they are both always on the move to new schools, where they are never able to establish their core friends, so they want the trust and security that comes with friendship despite whatever they suffer. Jim understands his setbacks and desires. So, he tries his best to make friends whenever he is in a new school. On the other hand, Holden understands his instability to make long-lasting relationships; but, he memorializes his friendships through his writing as a way to acknowledge his emotions and move …show more content…

When Holden goes to his third new school, Pencey high school, the school kicks him out by the end of the year. His history teacher notes, "I flunked you [Holden] in history because you knew absolutely nothing" and Holden responds with, “I know that, sir. Boy, I know it. You couldn't help it”(10). Holden ignores his history teacher, who is his friend. Even though his friend consoles him and the school expels him, Holden does not care that he fails all his subjects and school. When the psychiatrist and Holden’s family ask him whether he is going to apply himself at school, he answers, “I swear it’s a stupid question… to know the truth, I don’t know what I think about it”(213-214). Regardless his family worries for his well-being, he is indifferent to failing school because he understands he will go back to school despite being expelled three times. He also does not take school seriously since he does not feel in control to make the decision to go back to school. In contrast, Jim’s parents force Jim into adversity by constantly moving him to new schools, so he cannot settle at one school and progress academically, whenever he does move to a new school, he tries his best academically and socially. Yet, Holden does the opposite, he intentionally flunks school and his parents force him back to school, which only brings himself more

Get Access