preview

Historical Debates Are The Most Common, And Often Most

Good Essays

Historical debates are the most common, and often most effective, tool for which new study and scholarly perspectives are forged. The topic of municipalization might not seem at first glance like a vessel for heated scholarly debate; however, once one peels back the curtain, several lines of argument arise. Municipalization, in the classical sense, is the effective bringing-into-the-fold of institutions and governments under the control of a larger body. This particular inquiry will focus on the Roman Empire, and one particular source of law that has sparked a wider discussion on the phenomena of municipalization in the entirety of the Roman sphere-of-influence, the Tabula Heracleensis. More detail will be given to the specific aspects of …show more content…

The most pertinent aspects of Scott’s study to the Tabula Heracleensis are censuses, standardization of weights and measurements, and the organization of trans-regional transportation. These things are all mentioned in some form in the Tabula, and thus we must try and apply Scott’s theory to it. Scott essentially believes that states cannot possibly understand the intricacies of social phenomena and any attempt at large-scale standardization (or municipalization) is carried out through the coercive force of the state and will likely result in a negative social environment. This is shown best through the quote, “Because local standards of measurement were tied to practical needs, because they reflected particular cropping patterns and agricultural technology, because they varied with climate and ecology, because they were ‘an attribute of power and an instrument of asserting class privilege,’ and because they were ‘at the center of bitter class struggle,’ they represented a mind-boggling problem for statecraft.” In a rather long-winded way, Scott is asserting that governments often cannot account for the social, economic, and cultural methodologies that go in to a particular aspect of daily life. This will become key once applied to the Tabula.
As for Edward Bispham’s work From Asculum to Actium: The Municipalization of Italy from the Social War to Augustus, Bispham has a different take on Municipalization this time specifically

Get Access