Romance is portrayed through many viewpoints and understood differently. Yet, there are many novels out there that only cater to the white audience and magnify the importance of heteronormative relationships. Many people see romance films as a form to either fulfill something they do not have in their own personal relationship or as a simple stress reliever. However, romance in America is too whitewashed and does not take into consideration other races or sexual identification. Disney movies for the most part portray happy romance endings and stick to white characters. However, we never care to realize the deeper meaning of what they are trying to portray or do not portray at all. In this paper, I will rewrite my own queer version of Disney’s Mulan I and II in …show more content…
Growing up, she was different in comparison to the other little girls. Her parents would always scold her every time they would go out to family events because she had the tendency of playing with boys and digging up worms from the dirt. She disliked having to wear makeup and dresses, but still did it because her mother would not stop bugging her until she obey. It is a tradition in China for young girls to go to a matchmaker who determines whether they are ready to marry or not. Mulan had an appointment with a matchmaker but got there late and embarrassed her whole family by destroying the whole place. In this case, many thought that Mulan was just not fit to be normal. However, she really was a lesbian and was too scare to disappoint her family. She couldn’t really hide her truth inner self anymore. Many thought that she was going through a rebellious stage to demonstrate that she had something to prove but in reality she was trying to break free of her constraints. Yet, she did not know how to exactly do it without hurting her family even more than she already
Mu Ying was already been different because of her various qualities, “Though in her fifties,she didn't have a single gray hair;she was a little plump,but because of her long legs and arms she appeared rather queenly”(Jin,82). This quote examines her physical characteristics which exceeded expectations for a woman her age.So, her being a free spirit made it even harder for people to except her, like when Mu was explaining the love she yearned from a man and Bare Hips’ mother intervened. Jin explains, “You're wrong,Mu Ying;You have your own man, who doesn't lack an arm or a leg. It's wrong to have others' men and more wrong to pocket their money”(Jin,84). Bare Hips is explaining how in their society, you can’t just choose to have sex with whoever you want once you make a commitment, this shows the societies heavily family oriented mindset. So, this sort of behavior,by Mu Ying, had been so known to the society as a whole,so much so,that even when her husbands’ character was questioned; Mu Ying was the recipient of most of the backlash. Hence, when Meng Su emerges spontaneously from the crowd and begs for liberation of his wife to the Red Guard,Jin explains, “Old Whore doesn't deserve that good-hearted man;She's heartless and knows only how to sell her thighs”(Jin,83). Bare Hips’ mother is putting a strong emphasis on good versus evil, Mu Ying being the evil, and this strong emphasis is intended to
Mulan is also unlike any princess movie because it isn't a perfect fairy tale. Perhaps the only other Disney princess movie that isn't a major fantasy is Pocahontas. Both movies are based on somewhat true events, where women are often face stereotypical negativity just for being females. In Pocahontas and Mulan are also of different ethnicities in comparison to the other princesses, and are both courageous fighters. Pocahontas is
In their journal article of “Hetero-Romantic Love and Heterosexiness in Children's G-Rated Films,” Karin Martin and Emily Kazyak discussed how the animated Disney films as well as G-rated movies construct heterosexuality to young viewers – children, as they should not contain any of heterosexual scenes. According to the authors, young children are seemingly involved deeply in media world as it is a fruitful chapter of their sexual socialization; animated Disney films or other G-rated movies are what they are oftentimes engaged and attracted. It is always plotted as a stunning, beautiful lady waits for a brave, handsome guy to come to her life, then they would live happily ever after since the movies mark relationships between opposite sex repeatedly,
Prior to these circumstances happening, she is a “little girl of seven” (page 20). She is respectful, small (hence “little girl”) child with six siblings and as such she is probably considered insignificant or unassuming. She is only at the beginning of her journey toward full potential as a victorious warrior which comes to fruition afterward in her life. After Fa Mu Lan establishes herself as a strong, capable woman warrior who contrasts with the little girl she used to be, she marries, becomes a caring mother and “she is beautiful” (page 39). Fa Mu Lan has gone through three developmental stages now: child, warrior, and mother. Maxine Kingston uses these stages as a way to depict how she wishes she could be and also represents Fa Mu Lan’s dynamism as a
There are many connection between the movie Mulan and the ancient Confucian guidelines. In Mulan, when Fa Zhuo (her father) gets called to war, the mother -Fa Li, looks like she want to stand up and say that her husband is too old and weak but doesn’t. Fa Li keeps quiet and doesn’t say anything because one of the Five Key Relationships in Confucian. The relationship is husband to wife. The husband is the more superior in this relationship and the wife has to listen to him and accept his choice which is why she didn’t say anything.
Lin wants to go beyond her horizons, explore her personality, and learn more about other people's backgrounds. Throughout the story, Lin changes as a young person as she becomes more self-aware of her culture, she also explores other people's points of view and background while shaping her character and identity. Lin is a changing person; she wants to learn and grow. During the story, the character starts to move away from her culture. She begins to hang out with teens who are not Chinese, which makes her mother very upset.
In the movie, Mulan, she is caught between having to stay at home and become a wife, which is her proper role in society or go fight in a war in her father’s name. After a while, they discovered that she had been a woman the whole time. I feel like they were more angry that she was a woman and fought better than most of the men there. They kicked her out, of course, and later saved them and the emperor, but was still shunned. Chi-Fu told Shang, “Tis a woman. She will never be worth anything.” This shows that Chi-Fu wants her to be a woman, just like he thought she should be. He even admitted that she would not be worth anything or be a impacting role in society. This shows even if she did risk
We need to understand that the filial piety presented in the movie with the one in the original legend is different, because in the movie Disney portrayed back the filial piety based on American people’s understanding and stereotypes on Confucianism. In this way Mulan described as a free individual who does not want to be bounded by the strict rules of Confucianism. Although, most of the time Mulan expresses her refusal to Confucianism, she still represents the value of filial piety to her father by disguising herself as a man warrior and taking her father’s duty in a war. In this sense, Disney tried to show Mulan’s dutiful character by bringing out Mulan’s “manly” and rebellious personality. However, in order to strengthen Mulan’s head-strong personality, Disney deliberately lessened the value of obedience and replaced it with Mulan’s pursuit of identity. In this sense, Mulan is described as being confused of her real identity. She is given two difficult choices between fulfilling her role as a potential wife or listening to her own calling (She wants to find her own love without the interference of other people, including her parents). Moreover, the Ballad never explicitly tell the relationship between Mulan and her parents; but everyone can assume that Mulan does not have “a close relationship” with her parents unlike the one depicted in the Disney’s version. Because in filial
Is Disney’s Mulan Done Right In the Disney movie Mulan we see that Mulan is taking the traditions of what a Chinese woman was to do so that she could go out and fight in the war instead of her elderly father. So she so much as breaks the rules and does what no other woman is to do and that is to not do her duties as a woman.
She fought for twelve years and gained high glory, but she refused any reward and just wanted to retired to her hometown. Mulan, the ancient Chinese heroine who is filial piety and righteousness. She replaced her father into army and defeated the invasion of peoples and spread through the ages. The emperor of the Tang Dynasty bestowed filial strong general. Mulan is a heroine one of the four ancient Chinese legend who is China Southern and Northern Dynasties very strong heroine. Her story is a tragic hero epic. Mulan first appeared in the Northern and Southern a narrative poem, "Mulan", the poem about work in Northern and Southern Dynasties Northern Wei, originally included in the Southern Chen's "ancient and modern recorded music." Monk Chi Carpenter in "ancient music record," said: Magnolia unknown. More than 300 words long, after the Sui and Tang literati polish. "Mulan" was included in the secondary school textbooks, by millions of people for generations chanting song. Mulan's story and image are on the stage, holding the stage. Her spirit inspired thousands of sons and daughters to defend the country. As one male from each family is called to serve in the army to defend China from invaders. However, her father is old and weak and her younger brother is just a child, so she decides to take his place and farewell to her parents. After twelve years of war, the army returns and the
Mulan had a hard time catching up with the other soldiers since she wasn’t used to that type of work. The temptation was when Shang saw that Mulan was having a hard time catching up with the others and order her to go back home. Mulan rejects the offer and tries hard to prove herself to the Captain. Her atonement to her father is when she was improving in her training and succeeds in impressing him. Her apotheosis is when she was finally discovered after getting hurt during combat.
Hua Mulan or Fa Mulan is the story of a Chinese warrior women that lived during the Southern and Northern Dynasties of China and fought 12 years in the Chinese army dressed as a man without anybody noticing it. The story of Mulan is based on the Chinese ballad, poem, known as the ballad of Mulan. The story of Mulan tells the story of a girl who loved his father immensely and when she finds out that the Emperor is requiring a male member of each family in the realm, and since her father was very aged and his only son was still a child, she does not doubt about taking his father’s place on the army. Contrary to the Disney movie, the real Mulan was well trained in martial arts, so it was not very difficult for her to play the role of
The Disney film Mulan, begins with the Huns, namely the corrupt army, invading China. Meanwhile, in a village a young woman desired for the true reflection of herself to be revealed, with this intention it sparked a flame in her heart to pursue a prohibited job as an imperial soldier. To explain in depth, because the Hans invade China the emperor called for the training of recruit soldiers, choosing one male from each family to mandatorily fight in the war. Her father was injured, yet he was still chosen. This is a pivotal moment as the character is on the brink of a breaking point. With nothing left to lose she scurries away like a thief in the night, however she is not alone as her ancestors are awaken and sends help from a forbidden god named “Mushu”. Whom unto their knowledge is “The Great Stone Dragon”, however Mushu destroys his stone statue and its left up to him to save her. On her journey to the training camp Mulan practices her new identity and it is here she meets Mushu. Upon her arrival, to the training camp she stirs up trouble and immediately because the runt of the group, granted because of Mushu’s guidance. She gradually becomes a seasoned soldier. With the engraved desire to see her thrive, Mushu decides to write a fake letter from General Li ordering the troops to go to war. Mulan is thrusted into the battlefield and uses the adrenaline of the moment to save the troop, by creating an avalanche to smote out the Hun army, however she is wounded and it reveals her identity. Her life is spared but, she is expelled from the army. Left alone she surprisingly notices, that a few of the Huns survived, indeed she must warn the others. At first, they ignored her, consequently this led to the capturing of the emperor. Mulan comes up with another plan to save the emperor and the city from the Huns. Her bravery is rewarded and she is offered a position, regardless no place is like home to her. In the Disney film Mulan, the main character heroine exemplifies determination on her journey to becoming a soldier by defying traditions and broadening the horizons of what it means to be a woman.
For my final paper where we had to pick a topic from current popular culture, I decided to write my paper with the focus on Disney movies. More particularly with the focus on the Disney princess movies. When it comes to the Disney movies they have always been and will always be such a huge part of our society. While growing up most children grow up watching these movies and get the idea that that is what they want to be when they grow up. When you ask a young girl what she wants to be when she is older there is a good chance that she will say that she wants to be a princess when she grows up. I have always been such a huge fan of Disney movies and I have a feeling I always will be. I found it very interesting this semester when we spend the short class period talking about the Disney female and male characters. It is rather interesting and something that I can say that I really never noticed before but the fact that the majority of all the female characters all had the same face shape. Whereas the males there were none two that were the same. However for this paper I will be looking into the relationship to cultural meanings about gender and other identity markers, such as race, sexuality, and cultural norms as seen in some of the more classic well known Disney movies.
“So to spend a life of endless bliss; Just find who you love through true love 's kiss…” For nearly eight decades, Disney films have been selling their definition of true love, a term that is constantly changing under influence of development of feminism and therefore reflecting our culture’s shifting values. Throughout waves of feminism movements, following the changing definition of true love, we can see that woman characters in these films gradually grow from empty pictures dependent on men in the early years to lively figures with individuality and strong minds. These women characters provide a historical view of how women stand out to break their formulaic roles and identify themselves against the stereotypical gender schema.