preview

Hastrup's Essay The Inarticulate Mind

Decent Essays

Hastrup (1995) in his essay “The inarticulate mind” opens with “Questions of consciousness entail endless other questions”, this is certainly the case trying to answer the question, is consciousness internal or does it have an external dimension? That I only found more questions while investigating is not important, for it is that people do treat consciousness as something social and that makes it anthropologically relevant.
Does an anthological view have bearing, or should there be a philosophical or just scientific approach only? Philosophy gives us the computational theory of mind and defines consciousness as just information and processing. Research has extended this theory to at least seven primate species (Devaine, et al., 2017) So technologically …show more content…

the idea that a western child’s idea of consciousness is built from the external adult view that it receives. Looking at my own children and grandchildren growing up, I could not deny that they had consciousness from a very early age. James describes how part of this consciousness; this self is tied up with being “big”. Adult words of “when you are a big girl” and “my how tall you are”. Size is just a relative thing, not internal, it is the outside that builds a consciousness based on how “big” they are. And this in turn is related to how grown-up they are. It also proposes and other of the consciousness questions in what does it mean to be an adult when you are not yet considered one? Their habitas starts with the family group and latter extends to the school group, their field is really just trying to figure life out, and they are vulnerable as they do not have large reserves of capital for they are starting life. This lack of social capital means that words such as “big” can relate the childhood to an idea of shame or pride in their relationship to that “big”. Thereby showing that consciousness developing more effect of the external that internal on

Get Access