preview

Grief In The Book Thief And The Prisoner Of Azkaban

Decent Essays

While grief is a central theme to both The Book Thief and The Prisoner of Azkaban, the novels have a disagreement about what grief looks like. Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban supports the idea of a five stage cycle of grief, as theorized by Kubler and Ross. In contrast, The Book Thief does not focus on stages of grief. Instead, the novel takes a look at a duo-faceted idea of grief, which are pain and anger. The two novels are inherently different because of who their narrators are; Death is the narrator of Zusak’s novel, and a Rowling’s narrator for the story is a presumably human third party. Grief in The Book Thief is very atypical to what many describe it as, whereas The Prisoner of Azkaban shows the grieving process as cyclic as typically theorized.
Grief in The Book Thief has almost an uninvolved view of grief. The novel focuses on the events that result in grief itself, but do not follow up on grief as a continuing process. In most events within the novel, Death, the narrator, discusses what happens to Liesel and how she breaks down in that moment. In the excerpt examined from Part 5, “The Showdown: June 24”, Liesel is first described as feeling extreme pain over her mother being let go by the Mayor and his wife from her clothes washing services (Zusak, 260). Later on, the narrator says “Her sadness left her and she was overwhelmed with anger.” (261). For the remainder of the chapter, Liesel stays angry, even going as so far to tell Isla, the mayor’s wife, off (262-263). After this point, her anger and grief over her mother losing her last client (260) is not mentioned again. The grief, in the eyes of the narrator, seems to stay in that singular moment, and does not impact any future choices. Even later on in the book, when everyone she loves dies as the result of a bombing, the readers only see her grief in the moment, and nothing beyond it (538). In contrast, Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban shows grief in a very cyclic and continuing process. The five stages of grief, as theorized by Kubler and Ross, is as follows: denial, anger, bargaining, depression, and acceptance (Smaldone and Uzzo, 425). The cycle is more visible when looking at the Harry Potter series as a whole, but cycles

Get Access