preview

Giufa And The Judge Sparknotes

Decent Essays

Why would any author waste time and talent on a story that seems to lack relevance or meaning? Furthermore, the story of "Giufa and the Judge" not only presents a flawed depiction of parenting, indirectly glorifies thievery, and portrays governmental corruption, but it also endorses a set of morally questionable teachings, offering no constructive value to its audience and rendering it an unproductive narrative lacking beneficial lessons. Once upon a time, a foolish man named Giufa was gathering herbs one night when he noticed the moon's intermittent appearance behind the clouds. Observing this phenomenon, he exclaimed repeatedly, "It appears, it appears! It sets, it sets." Some nearby thieves, skinning a stolen calf, heard Giufa and mistook …show more content…

Either Giufa is so oblivious that he has never been outside to examine the moon, or he is so uneducated that he doesn't even recognize what the moon is. Even if we accept the previous point as plausible, why would the thieves mistake a man screaming in the sky for a group of well-educated policemen? Assuming Giufa is just an uneducated man fascinated by the moon, how could his exclamations be mistaken for the voices of multiple policemen? And even if Giufa did sound like multiple policemen, why would they reveal their positions and scare away the criminals with pointless yelling? Some might say that perhaps the Italian policemen are very loud, which is why Giufa's shouting scared the thieves away. To this, I argue, why would the thieves abandon all their hard work just because of some random man yelling? It makes no sense for a country like Italy, known for its rich culture and history, to employ fools resembling Giufa in its justice departments. Either the thieves enjoy wasting their efforts, or Italy is burdened by incompetent officials in its justice system. Some might disagree, suggesting the thieves were just being overly

Get Access