In the documentary, Frontline: Prisoners of Silence, Facilitated Communication and its controversies are discussed. Facilitated Communication is a practice that claims to give nonverbal autistic people the ability to express themselves. When first introduced, FC was heralded as revolutionizing the way people look at autism and mental retardation. It opened a door that many never thought existed. Unfortunately that door turned out to be dream of what could be.
Facilitated Communication has had many downfalls, ethically and financially. People invested significant amounts of time and money into learning and practicing this technique. Facilitators spent their own money on training and keyboards, and millions of public money was spent to put
…show more content…
I’d never heard of FC before and I was excited to hear about nonverbal autistic people having the ability to communicate their thoughts and feelings. I rationalized the children being able to write poetry and short stories to myself. I assumed that since they were lacking in motor capabilities that their bodies would compensate by giving them greater mental capabilities than the average person. I was excited and proud of everything the autistic persons had accomplished. When all the sexual abuse cases were being presented I was angry and confused. I couldn’t believe that someone was taking advantage of the autistic child’s inability to disclose their abuse. I couldn’t understand how the children knew the specific words used to describe their abuse, there’s only so much they could’ve learned from watching TV. The double blind experiment results left me dumbfounded. I thought that the facilitator might have had some influence in helping the autistic person type, but I never would’ve guessed that it was all the facilitator. I guess I wanted to believe just like others in the video. By the end of the video I was angry with Dr. Douglas Biklen, because no matter how much evidence he was given disproving FC, he ignored it and continued the practice. This can only negatively affect nonverbal autistic people and their families in the long
War is a hellish battleground where many lives are taken. In war there is constantly images and events that happen which can change a soldier’s life forever. In the book All Quiet on the Western Front Remarque uses the symbols of boots, butterflies and horses to advance the main theme in the novel, that war takes young men’s innocence away.
This video was very surprising, instructive, informative, depressing and occasionally infuriating. I have always known that there were a lot of factors that influence ones health, but I had never really expected it to be this disturbing reality. The video presents a lot of surprising information with any luck individuals will ask themselves serious questions like I did. Optimistically, after seen the video people can account to the things that need to be addressed in order to eliminate this factors and not be eager to judge a set of group of individuals.
Erich Remarque uses compelling symbols in chapter six of All Quiet on the Western Front, many of them have a significant meaning, only two have a powerful meaning. A shelled schoolhouse, in a sense brings the reader this sort of comfort because the feel of school brings them back to the good ole days. It is the days when you did not have to worry about things because mom and dad were there. The shelling part is another thing, it is showing the amount and the type of war going on. The violence in this time and place is unimaginable and the shelled schoolhouse is an example of the violence is being revealed. Remarque is trying to display to the reader that in this day and age of war they did not care about what they destroyed. He describes many bloody situations because he wants the reader to feel the pain and suffering how
In chapter four of Erich Remarque’s book All Quiet on the Western Front, Remarque uses sensory images. Putting extra sensory images into a scene gives the reader more idea of what’s happening “I hear aspirant for the frying pan” (52). By describing how excited the men are when they hear geese Remarque is, in a way, letting the reader know that, to soldiers at war the smallest thing can be the brightest beaken of hope. When Remarque outlines how happy the soldiers get over some simple geese, it really helps to show how while the war has helped the men grow up, they are still young boys. In the previous chapter Remarque used sensory images to make the boys seem more grown up by giving them power while beating Himmelstoss “It was a wonderful picture”
In All Quiet on the Western Front, author Erich Maria Remarque uses tactile imagery to emphasize that war is horrific. The main character Paul fights to stay alive every day while in the midst of World War 1 as a German soldier, but injuries are bound to happen at some point, ¨The surgeon pokes around in the wound and a blackness comes before my eyes.” (243). In this quote Remarque uses 2 examples of tactile imagery, movement and feelings. The details used to describe this scene makes you feel as if you were in the surgery with Paul.
Watching the Frontline Confessions documentary made me think about a lot of things. First of all I feel that what Detective Robert Glen Ford did was wrong. He abused his power of the badge to harshly interrogate innocent men. He spent continuous hours interrogating Daniel Williams in a small room, pressuring him into confessing to something that he didn’t commit. Ford threatened Daniel with the death penalty multiple times. When Daniel told him his side of the story, he called him a liar and said, “If you don’t start telling me the truth, you’re going to die.” I think one of the ironic things is that the detective was the only one lying in the interrogation. When Daniel Williams took the polygraph test he passed, but
In All Quiet on the Western Front, the author paints a realistic and gruesome tale of war. Many people believe that war is a glorious event. The author succeeds to show how gruesome and devastating war actually is. In many books, movies, and TV shows, war is described as glorious and good. War is not glorious or good from the beginning of time people have been at war and from that people have died. War is shown as the thing that gets the girl or the thing that makes people see you as a king and that people come back untouched. That is the false way the Hollywood and others have butchered the reality of war.
Rats scuttling around. Lice crawling everywhere. Diseases spreading like wildfire. Imagine living in conditions like this for weeks on end. Add bullets constantly whizzing past, bombs
All Quiet on the Western Front, by Erich Remarque, is a classic anti-war novel about the personal struggles and experiences encountered by a group of young German soldiers as they fight to survive the horrors of World War One. Remarque demonstrates, through the eyes of Paul Baumer, a young German soldier, how the war destroyed an entire generation of men by making them incapable of reintegrating into society because they could no longer relate to older generations, only to fellow soldiers.
Do you know anyone who has been in a world war? Do you know what happens to people in war? The novel All Quiet on the Western Front, by Erich Maria Remarque is the story of the German man Paul and how he copes with the war and how he gets through it. World War 1 was an international conflict which lasted from 1914 to 1918. War transforms people in many ways and nobody except those who have experienced it can understand the terrors. War can change whole societies, how people live in it, and how it runs. Many people go into war thinking that it will be very adventurous and fun because that's what they see in advertisement and propaganda. The reality of war is that it is brutal and you have to kill people to survive and every day you survive is
As a child, I often avoided confrontation by keeping my opinions to myself, no matter how offensive someone was. But when someone directed negative comments toward my autistic brother who could not defend himself, I lost my self-control. Witnessing the struggles Bo has gone through, I feel it is cruel and ignominious to belittle the battles autistic children deal with daily. I share this story to help disclose the need to treat others with the courtesy we all deserve.
Professor’s Comments: This is a good example of a book review typically required in history classes. It is unbiased and thoughtful. The Student explains the book and the time in which it was written in great detail, without retelling the entire story… a pitfall that many first time reviewers may experience.
In today’s society, we believe that all humans should be treated equal. We see this every day; on the news, blogs, social networking websites, worldwide campaigns. In her online journal article about life with a child with autism, “Tackling That Troublesome Issue of ABA and Ethics”, published in October of 2012, Ariane Zurcher argues that the issue of ABA therapy should affect either more than those individuals living with autism, or no one at all. ABA therapy is an applied behavior analysis in which patients with autism are motivated to do a certain task; they are often rewarded in hope of having an action come naturally. Zurcher dives into an article by Michelle Dawson, The Misbehavior of Behaviorists: Ethical Challenges to the Autism ABA Industry, which is so often used in Zurcher’s own article to back up her argument regarding ABA therapy. She explains how this argument stems from an inadequate definition of what equality is and how we should not use a therapy technique different from what we would use for a neurotypical individual, “If we really believe Autistic people (and children) deserve the same respect, are truly considered equal as those in the neurotypical population, ABA presents some real problems.” (Zurcher 1; par. 4)
" In this we can see that because they are different, they have been isolated and confined to be treated like guineapigs and many of the researchers don't even treat them or regard them as human beings. It tells us that basically the negative effects of being different heavily outweigh the positive effects. The Babies are also very different. They had all the symptoms of autism yet they can communicate telepathically.
I agree about the views that they expressed, because being diagnosed with Face Blindness can cause numerous obstacles in their lives. In my view, this condition is saddening because not recognizing themselves or even someone else can frustrate a person and also allow them to lose friends. In addition, now these people have found other ways to determine who people are. For example, a person that does their hair the same way can allow that person who has the condition to identify who that person is by the way he or she does their hair every day. Some might object to watching this video, of course, on the grounds that this is not a significant issue because a person may rarely find or hear about people having this condition and in the video it