preview

External Restraint Theory Paper

Decent Essays

Violence is a serious matter that impacts communities in many ways. Violence comes in many forms. Violence can include vocal arguments between people that do not agree about some topic, it can be physical violence where people fight, or it can become very serious where someone may die as a result. Violence often occurs unexpectedly; imagine being out after a week of hard work and stress. You might be looking to relax with friends, having a few drinks and engaging in social activities. With violence, what often occurs is unexpected and the consequences have not been considered. Society must understand and recognize the causes and reasons how violence can lead to homicide or suicide. There are two main theories that define the type of violence …show more content…

The theory discusses how people seek to eliminate their intense feelings of anger and frustration by killing the source of the perceived anger. The theory also implies that individuals have some desire to kill. Thio, Taylor, and Schwartz attempt to explain through the External Restraint Theory “why individuals who experience intense frustration choose to commit homicides or commit suicide” (Thio et al, 2013, p. 78). Although both homicide and suicide seem similar in that death is the result, these are two very different violent acts. Homicides are voluntary actions committed by the individual upon a victim who does not necessarily wish to die. Suicide is a voluntary act committed by an individual who has decided to take their own life. The External Restraint Theory maintains that “when one experiences “strong external restraint” they are more likely to choose “other-directed aggression” (homicide) whereas when one experiences intense frustration they are likely to choose “self-directed aggression” which is suicides, which is “weak restraint” (Thio et al, 2013, p. 78). People react differently to stress, emotional challenges, frustration, and anger. Some personal problems that lead to heightened levels of frustration and anger include; financial problems, physical problems, or emotional abuse. When some individual experiences such a high level of frustration that …show more content…

The Subculture of Violence Theory states that individuals turn to violence as a survival mechanism and not as a reaction to frustration and anger. In this theory, the individual is exposed and experiences violence on a daily or regular basis and therefore equates violence with survival, violence and killing become part of a lifestyle and ingrained behavior. According to Thio, Taylor, and Schwartz they maintain, “because subculture of violent has such a grip on the poor that they engage in a wider range of violent behavior than the non-poor’ (Thio et al, 2013, p. 79). Low income neighborhoods are more vulnerable to violence and crime and therefore the culture within these neighborhoods are more likely to accept violent behavior as normal and acceptable. In communities where violence becomes acceptable the level of violence rises and may lead to violent crime and killing as a means of control or survival. For example; some individuals might be influenced by gangs or become affiliated with criminal groups. Individuals who choose violence or are influenced by the promises of gangs for support and safety begin to adopt a culture of violence and criminal activity. In gang environments, the gang begins to assume the role of family which further deepens the culture of violence within these communities.

Get Access