preview

Evolutionary Hypothesis Controversy: A Genetic Analysis

Decent Essays

Most treehoppers have an expansion of the T1 (1st thoracic segment; prothorax) dorsal sclerite which has led to a number of hypothesis for it’s evolutionary novelty (Stegmann,1998). The origin of novelty is one of the major issues in biology due to its inherent definitional variability (Brigandt & Love, 2012). According to Wagner & Lynch (2010) most definitions of evolutionary novelty can be summarized into two categories based on functional and structural novelty consisting of the genetic origin of such traits. The treehopper helmet may be considered functionally novel due to its unique adaptations to the environment. Although its morphological and genetic basis of novelty remain a controversy (Heffer & Pick, 2013). The adaptive potential …show more content…

Prud’homme et al. (2011) demonstrated that the wing specific gene nubbin was expressed in a similar pattern in the helmet formation as in wings and arrived at the conclusion that the treehopper helmet was serially homologous to the T1 wing. In addition the authors speculated that the evolution of the helmet is due to a change in an unknown genetic mechanism downstream of Scr (sex combs reduced), which is part of the hox gene family. Thereby suggesting that the evolution of the treehopper helmet is due to genes that were under repression by hox genes. Moczek (2011) speculated that the tree hoppers evolved a wing like structure through re- emergence of a repressed developmental program of the wing. Clark-Hachtel and Tomoyasu (2016) proposed that the treehopper helmet might be partially homologous to the wings based on the fact that the treehopper helmet and the beetle carinated margin of Tribolium beetle both originate from the T1 tergum and it was shown that the reduction of the repression of Scr lead to formation of wings in the beetle. Conversely Yoshizawa (2012), proposes that the lack of evidence for the Scr mechanism in treehoppers might be due to pleiotropy and

Get Access