preview

Essay On Haitian Imperialism

Decent Essays

James compares Toussaint Louverture's rule to the early Soviet Communist regime following the October Revolution under Lenin, and blames his failure to establish a stable government was not an error in terms of policy, but rather the execution of such policies. In attempting to incorporate the former leadership and bureaucracy of Saint Domingue, James argues that Toussaint had the correct intent, but the development of the government in such a fashion failed, succumbing to the pressures of a class-based imperialism. The work of C.L.R. James is of the highest prestige of the body of work on the Haitian Revolution, in fact, the vast majority of the other works referenced cites The Black Jacobins as the core study of the Revolution and uphold the work to the point where the credibility thereof is indisputable. The widespread citation of the work also emphasizes the incredible influence of James’s work on the study of the Haitian Revolution on later scholars, demonstrating greater connections between the arguments James provides with the arguments of other historians, most obviously Dubois. On the other hand, …show more content…

By understanding the development of the Haitian State, one can therefore derive the dynamics of power built into the rising nation. Moreover, James analyzes well the external forces of control on Haiti, which allows a better understanding of the ability of the state to control its own future. Together, these arguments provide excellent examples of the inequalities within Haiti and externally effecting the nation, and the development of these inequalities as an inherent part of the Haitian and world economies. In such arguments, The Black Jacobins supports the assertion that the changes created in the revolution survived only because of the static qualities created after the

Get Access