Introduction In 1985 after federal deregulation of natural gas pipelines Enron was formed through a merger of Houston Natural Gas, and Nebraska pipeline company Internorth. Enron went on to create energy derivatives and in 1990 formed Enron Finance Corp. By 1996 Enron had also formed Enron Capital and Trade Resources increasing their growth from $2 billion to $7 billion and increasing division employment from 200 to 2,000. In 1999 Enron entered the technology market by creating Enron Online (EOL). By August of 2000 Enron stock hit its zenith at $90.56/share and the firm was widely admired and emulated. Behind the scenes Enron faced increasing market competition and energy prices began to decline as the world economy entered into a recession. Enron began to use related party transactions and special purpose entities (SPEs) to obscure the firm’s leverage ratios in order to maintain their credit rating. It would be the use of the SPEs that eventually cause Enron to materially restate their financials resulting in their insolvency and demise in 2001 (Thomas, 2002).
Issues
Numerous factors impacting Enron lead to perceived solutions exacerbating the issues and escalating the magnitude of fraud perpetuated. As time progressed Enron faced increasing competition while simultaneously enduring the effects of the beginning of economic recession. The above issue increased the pressure on executives to continue posting performance numbers despite the reality of outside
Enron, the natural gas provider turned trader of natural gas commodities and in 1994, electric, was once touted as the seventh largest company in America. Kenneth Lay, founder, began changing Enron from just a provider into a financial energy powerhouse. Lay took advantage of the dot-com boom of the late 1990’s by creating Enron Online, an internet trading platform. Internet stocks were valued at astronomical prices and were all the rage on wall street, who accepted the increasing prices as normal (Investopedia). On December 2, 2001 Enron declared chapter 11 bankruptcy, resulting in the loss of twenty thousand jobs and billions of investor and creditor dollars. Enron, once designated as "America 's Most Innovative Company" by Fortune for six years consecutively, enacted massive financial fraud at the fault of its top level executives: Kenneth Lay, Jeffery Skilling, and Andrew Fastow.
Enron took on the role of a ‘gas bank’ and started operations in 1989, where, it bought gas from suppliers and sold it to consumers, profiting from a fee charged for carrying out the transaction. The company flourished under the business model which impressed Lay, who then created a new division called Enron Finance Corp in 1990 and assigned Skilling to take charge of operations. Enron Finance Corp. soon dominated the market with more contacts and contracts with regard to suppliers and consumers compared to any of its competitors.
Enron is an energy trading, electric utilities and natural gas formed in 1931. It was merged to Houston’s Natural Gas Company in 1985 by Kenneth Lay. It was the most innovative company for 6 years until it came crashing down in a terrible scandal known as the Enron Scandal which led to the suspension of Arthur Anderson. Enron’s stock price decreased rapidly and abruptly collapsed and filed for bankruptcy.
The word “fraud” was magnified in the business world around the end of 2001 and the beginning of 2002. No one had seen anything like it. Enron, one of the country’s largest energy companies, went bankrupt and took down with it Arthur Andersen, one of the five largest audit and accounting firms in the world. Enron was followed by other accounting scandals such as WorldCom, Tyco, Freddie Mac, and HealthSouth, yet Enron will always be remembered as one of the worst corporate accounting scandals of all time. Enron’s collapse was brought upon by the greed of its corporate hierarchy and how it preyed upon its faithful stockholders and employees who invested so much of their time and money into the company. Enron seemed to portray that the goal of corporate America was to drive up stock prices and get to the peak of the financial mountain by any means necessary. The “Conspiracy of Fools” is a tale of power, crony capitalism, and company greed that lead Enron down the dark road of corporate America.
Enron’s demise was led by the arrogance and greed of senior executives. The belief was they had to be the best business leaders in the United States. Many also believe that there was a conflict of interest with the auditing firm because not only did they serve as the auditing firm, they also served as a consulting firm to Enron. This enabled them to fabricate financial statements by building assets and hiding debt from investors. The loss of the recorded $1.2 billion shareholders equity meant that many victims of this fraud lost their jobs and their retirement funds.
WorldCom, for example, was facing a downward trend in their industry. The telecommunications company was going south, especially thanks to text messaging and the internet. In addition, the government denied them the ability to merge with Sprint (a $129 billion dollar merger), which quickly halted their growth. WorldCom had built a growth strategy built upon mergers and acquisitions, instead of growing product lines and larger marketing campaigns. So when the federal government denied their ability to grow large enough to discourage competition, they had to look elsewhere to increase shareholder profitability. Another venue of motivation was of course based upon the Fraud Triangle. This diagram or model consists of three things for one to commit fraud: pressure, opportunity, and rationalization. WorldCom had all three things – leading them straight towards disaster. The CFO was facing immense pressure from stakeholders and the executive board to increase profits (and growth), he had the opportunity as he controlled the books, and he either had justification or, more probably, a lack of ethics. Applying this triangle to Enron, all three factors were present. Enron was facing immense pressure to continue their standing as one of the top 10 fortune 500 companies, as well as continuing to be named one of the world’s most
The story of Enron is truly remarkable. As a company it merely controlled the electricity, natural gas and communications sectors of the world. It reported (key word, reported) revenues over one hundred billion US dollars and was presented America’s Most Innovative Company by Fortune magazine for six sequential years. But, with power comes greed and Enron from its inception employed people who set their eyes upon money, prestige, power or a combination of the three. The gluttony took over sectors which the company could not operate proficiently nor successfully.
Instead, it was such massively deceptive accounting alteration that it raised questions about the proper definition and scope of the white-collar crime. While only a few major employees and members of the company were involved in this fraudulent activity, yet it affected the life of several hundred thousand Americans. As the investigation report about Enron was publically released, the AAA+ credit rated company collapsed instantly making hundreds and thousands homeless and jobless. This had a serious impact on the stability of the stock exchange as well. The collapse of the company was not only composed of the financial stability of the company bit as they have also destroyed their reputation at the global
In this case of Enron the corporate culture played a vital role of its collapse. It was culture of full of moneymaking strategies and greed, in the firm Greed was good and money was God. There was no or very little regards for ethics or the law, they operated as there was no law and ethics in the world (Enron Ethics, 2010). Such culture affected all the employees of the firm from top to down. Organizational culture supported unethical behaviour and practises, corruption, cheating and those were all widespread. Many executives and managers knew that the firm is following illegal and unethical practises, but the executives and the board of directors did not knew how to change this unethical culture, the firm used creative accounting and were making showing misleading profits every day. Reputation management enabled them carry on their illegal and unethical operations. Moreover if the company made huge Revenue in the unethical way then the new individual who joined the firm would also have to practise all those unethical practises to survive in the company. All of the management was filled by greed and ambition, their decisions became seriously imperfect, thus the firm fell back and managers had to pay in the price in the form imprisonment and fines. Greed is the main key factors that brought the Enron “the most innovative company” to downfall. Enron was looking into the ways of
Enron was the result of a merger of Houston Natural Gas and Internorth. The company benefitted from being the first mover in their market, setting an internal growth strategy at an aggressive increase in revenue of 15% per year. “It became the largest energy trader in the world, with $40 billion in revenue in 1998, $60 billion in 1999, and
Enron was a business conglomerate during the 1990s, formed by the merger of smaller oil and energy companies. Houston executives Kenneth Lay (Chairman), Jeffrey Skilling (chief executive officer (CEO) and Andrew Fastow (chief financial officer (CFO) parlayed their new mega-company into a favorite Wall Street company, bragging of record profits with negligible losses. During the 1990s, the three senior executives changed Enron from a traditional gas and electricity company into a $150 billion energy corporation. For instance, from 1998 to 2000 only, Enron’s returns rose from approximately $31 billion to over $100 billion, making the company to be the seventh biggest conglomerate of the Fortune 500. Unidentified to nearly everybody, this picture was the result of one of the largest swindles in financial history (Ferrell, Fraedrich & Ferrell, 2013).
The story of Enron begins in 1985, with the merger of two pipeline companies, orchestrated by a man named Kenneth L. Lay (1). In its 15 years of existence, Enron expanded its operations to provide products and services in the areas of electricity, natural gas as well as communications (9). Through its diversification, Enron would become known as a corporate America darling (9) and Fortune Magazine’s most innovative company for 5 years in a row (10). They reported extraordinary profits in a short amount of time. For example, in 1998 Enron shares were valued at a little over $20, while in mid-2000, those same shares were valued at just over $90 (10), the all-time high during the company’s existence (9).
Enron was the largest company for energy and natural gas made possible through the merging of Houston Natural Gas and InterNorth based in Omaha. The merger made Enron the largest energy trader in the country and the seventh largest in the world. The company advanced into new fields of business by launching a broadband service unit and Enron online, where people can go to trade commodities. Enron rose quickly to become one of America’s most valuable company. It had a peak of $100 billion in revenue and it was taking the market by storm. The company had many major projects and had plans to expand into foreign countries. With the much celebrated success, Enron would have a greater fall than its rise because of mismanagement and poor accounting practices. The company was known for hiring the smartest individuals in the country, but that did not prevent the company from its embarrassing collapse. Enron collapsed with millions of dollars of pension funds and about 5600 people were unemployed. The company that was thought to be performing in the eyes of the public was actually in deep trouble behind the curtains. The big question many people ask is what caused Enron’s collapse? The truth of the matter is that, Enron’s collapse was not caused by just one thing, it was caused by many things such as theft, lies, poor accounting practices, lack of auditing, political factors, and conspiracy. This is what Enron represented about a decade after the merger, this is how the company became
Enron was founded in July of 1985. Enron was an electricity and natural gas company which was a fortune 500 company and it was ranked the sixth largest energy company in the world. Enron’s stock went from a peak of $90.75 to $0.67. This was very detrimental to stockholders. Enron’s top executives sold their stock a long time before the stock price fell. A lot of lower level employees could not sell their stock because of deals they made with the company. This later caused a lot of these employees to lose their life savings and everything they had worked for. Enron used a very complex accounting method to trick the stock market. This method was called “mark to market” accounting. Enron used this method of accounting to predict and project their earnings in a long term period. These earnings were projected based on the long term energy contracts Enron was going to make. This could have been money that was not made at that point. This made Enron’s stock price skyrocket at a very fast pace, making a lot of employees and general public invest in the stock. Enron stock seemed to be a very secure and profitable investment which would make people lots of money. The Fortune 500 company went down very quickly. In August of 2001, the CEO of Enron, Jeffrey Skilling resigned. He randomly resigned and a lot of suspicions arose. His resignation was described to be because of personal reasons.
The first failure of Enron is that it lacked a solid accounting information system. Instead, the firm adopted a concept called mark to market. This is where all accounting records of a company’s assets were based on the prevailing market price. The failure of this system is that it allows the accountants to record the value of the assets and liabilities at any value. This orchestrates mass cover ups and conspiracy as revenues will be based on speculation and derivatives. In the end the financial statements produced are highly in accurate and do not show the true position of a corporation. For instance, through this accounting system Enron was able to show that its revenues were growing while in fact the revenues were non-existent in the first place. A good case in point is the offshore partnerships opened by the CFO Andrew Fastow, and Enron official. The strategic offshore partnerships were used by Enron to project revenues that were reported in the company’s financial statements (Seabury, n.d). Other deals such as the blockbuster live streaming movie using bandwidth technology was used to inflate the revenues of the company by recording projected revenues from such deals. In return, financial analysts gave the company’s stock a higher rating based on projected revenues and derivatives. This explains why Enron was the golden goose for Wall Street prior to its collapse. From the above analysis it is apparent that the accounting information