Ethan Remmel, a Bellingham, WA resident, was only 41 when he died on June 13, 2011, a year after being diagnosed with terminal colon cancer that quickly spread to his bones. Ethan was a psychology professor and father of two young sons. He took a lethal dose of crushed prescription sedatives to end his life. He was able to legally obtain that prescription from his physician under the state’s 2009 Death with Dignity Act. The law allows people living with deadly illnesses maintain control over their lives. Having that control maintained seems to improve the quality of life for someone at the end of their life. Dr. Remmel’s quality of life was critical to his happiness.
Brittany Maynard was 29 years old, living in San Francisco,
…show more content…
Because her body was young and healthy, she was likely to physically stay alive for a long time, but the cancer was eating her brain which would have caused her to suffer in hospice care for months while her family watched her deteriorate slowly. Even with palliative medication, she could develop morphine-resistant pain and lose her verbal, cognitive, and motor skills at any time. For her, that seemed like a nightmare to put her family through. She wanted to live the rest of the life she had left to the fullest, surrounding herself with family and friends, doing things she had always dreamt of doing and saying goodbye to her loved ones in her own time. Much like Dr. Rimmel, Brittany’s quality of life was critical to her happiness. Because the state of California has not authorized death with dignity. Brittany and her family had to move from their home to Portland, Oregon. Oregon was one of five states where death with dignity is legal.
Physician assisted death (PAD), is death made possible by a physician providing a patient with the means to end their life. There are compelling conclusions that argue for and against PAD, but when they are weighed against each other the arguments to legalize PAD by far outweigh the arguments against legalizing PAD. PAD should be legalized.
Banning something in our
The article “Brittany Maynard Death With Dignity Advocate for ‘Death With Dignity’ Dies” by Catherine E. Shoichet delivers the story of Brittany Maynard. She was diagnosed with brain cancer in 2012 and was told she had from 3-10 years to live. However, in another diagnose that she had she was told she only had about six months to live. Maynard graduated from Berkeley and obtained a Masters in Education from the University of Irvine. She was a California resident and could not obtain her wish of dying with assisted suicide here. She moved to Oregon and there she became a resident. In 2014 Brittany Maynard consumed the drugs and peacefully died at 29 years.
The article “Brittany Maynard Death With Dignity Advocate for ‘Death With Dignity’ Dies” by Catherine E. Shoichet delivers the story of Brittany Maynard. She was diagnosed with brain cancer in 2012 and was told she had from 3-10 years to live. However, in another diagnose that she had she was told she only had about six months to live. Maynard graduated from Berkeley and obtained a Masters in Education from the University of Irvine. She was a California resident and could not obtain her wish of dying with assisted suicide here. She moved to Oregon and there she became a resident. In 2014 Brittany Maynard consumed the drugs and peacefully died at 29 years.
Kara Tippets, a thirty-eight year old married Christian woman with four children suffered from metastatic breast cancer. Tippets strongly did not believe in assisted dying for many reasons. She slowly started accepting her condition over time and knew that her day of death was coming soon. Since her husband was a pastor, they strongly believed in the Christian way to fully live their lives to the best of their abilities. However, a twenty- nine year old woman named Brittany Maynard did not believe in assisted dying. She was diagnosed with a terminal brain tumor and decided to end her life before the tumor progressed and before her suffering worsened. Maynard strongly believed in the phrase “death with dignity” and was forced to move to Oregon from California to make physician-assisted dying legal. Only five states made physician-dying legal and California did not make it legal until after Maynard had passed away. Oregon, Vermont, Washington, and California were the other four states that made the procedure legal to any individual. Brittany Maynard had chosen to inject herself with lethal prescription with the assistance of a physician on November 1, 2014 to take her life away, but Kara Tippetts did not agree with her decision.
Brittany was educated by her doctor on the possible treatments which would prolong her life for a little amount of time. However, since her tumor was so large she would have to receive full head radiation where she would lose all her hair and be left with severe burns in her scalp. After talking with her family she decided that there would be no treatments to save her and that those treatments would worsen her life style. She considered dying in hospice care, meaning that she would refuse radiational treatment and live the rest of her days on morphine to lessen her pain. After realizing that morphine would make her suffer of personality changes and verbal and cognitive motion loss she decided to die while was she was young and was able to function on her own. She did not want her family to see her dying terribly ill at the hospice. Therefore, she decided to move to Oregon where she became educated on the topic and was able to contact a doctor to assist her with lethal medicine that she would self inject when she started feeling like her symptoms were unbearable in order to end her suffering. Giving her relief after
While many Americans assume “assisted suicide” or physician aid-in-dying (PAD) is unethical, they may not be fully aware of what it is and how it helps people. Imagine a loved one of yours was near the end of their life. The doctors predict only six months or less remain of their life and these next six months will consist of excruciating pain and will be almost too unbearable to comprehend. As the six months progress this person will lose the ability to eat. They will be forced to a diet of flaky ice chips which will put them in a state of relentless hunger making their body weaker and more painful than it had been before. They will also lose the ability to care for themselves and will find themselves relying on family members or complete strangers at times to care for their most private needs. After all this treatment, pain, embarrassment, and utter helplessness the patient will feel as if they have lost their dignity, they will feel as if they are a burden to everyone around them and will even become depressed in some cases. If the loved one lives in Washington State, Oregon, or Vermont they will then be faced with two options regarding the next six hypothetical months they can decide to take on the most unbearable six months of their life or they can resort to an alternative called “Death with Dignity” in which they will be administered a dose of medication from their physician that will take their life. The process is painless and can only be administered to patients
Brittany Maynard was a young woman in her twenties who received major news coverage over her decision to use euthanasia in order to end her brain-tumor-ridden life. After adventuring for months before the life-ending appointment, the terminally ill woman and her family moved to Oregon due to the state’s passage of the Death with Dignity law. On November 1st of 2014, Brittany Maynard received a fatal dose of barbiturates which ended her life while being surrounded by family and friends. She was 29 at time of her death (Egan, Fowler, & Keating,
In order to fulfill the act she had to move to another state where it was legal and ended her life by using Barbiturates that her doctor prescribed to her. After this event took place it created some thought to legalize assisted suicide. California, Colorado, Illinois, Nevada, and Rhode Island just to name some of the 12 states that have tried to legalize PAS several times have failed to do so. Many have considered how Maynard’s death can cause others to take up her actions and do the same. The choice to die, and has been only legalized in three U.S. states: Oregon, Washington, and Montana. In Oregon it was legalized in 1997 but is not referred to as physician assisted suicide but as physician aid in dying, in Washington it was legalized in 2008, and lastly in Montana in 2009. Physician assisted suicide should not become a legal option to individuals, because it is against religious beliefs, patients will be prompted to give up to soon, and it violates professional ethical
Physician-assisted suicide is defined as a physician providing either equipment or medication, or to inform the patient of the most available means, for the purpose of assisting the patient to end his or her own life. The people’s opinion support PAS according to a poll given in 1998. The majority 33% of people agreed that Physician assisted suicide should be made legal in a variety
Brittany Maynard, a young newlywed, was diagnosed with aggressive and fatal brain cancer. She moved to Oregon with her husband so she could have control at the end of her life under Oregon’s death with dignity law.
Physician assisted death (PAD) is the voluntary termination of one’s own life by the administration of a lethal substance with the direct or indirect assistance of a physician. PAD is a topic of discussion where one side believes that it will cause more harm than good because it conflicts with the physician's role as a healer, very difficult to control, and would pose a societal risk. While the other side believes that patients have the right to do what they want to their bodies and to end their suffering if they are terminally ill. Now there are plenty of other arguments for both sides and the two arguments make strong cases. For example, some say that the patient’s pain and suffering will end, patients
Since 1993, Compassion in Dying, which is a nonprofit charitable organization, has provided information, consultation, and emotional support to patients that were terminally ill and wanted to consider assisted dying by self-administration of medication as one of their end of life options. The team for this organization includes nurses, psychologists, physicians, and clergy as was as laypeople from the community who help patients, their families, and their physicians examine the choices available to achieve peaceful and humane deaths (Lee). To be eligible to use this Act a person must be a resident of Oregon, 18 years or older, capable of making and communication health care decisions for him or herself, mentally competent, and diagnosed with a terminal illness that will lead to death within six months. This article uses data from the files of Compassion in Dying, and they describe 34 individuals who approached Compassion wanting to use the Death with Dignity Act and who died during the first year of the Act’s implantation. A downfall to this Act that has caused some problems is delays in processing a
November 4th, 2014 Brittany Maynard ended her life that Saturday by physician-assisted suicide (Scott 2014). She had stage four brain cancer and was told in January that she had 6 months left to live. When Brittany was told the news she moved to Oregon where the law would allow her to receive physician-assisted suicide. “My glioblastoma is going to kill me and that 's out of my control. I 've discussed with many experts how I would die from it and it 's a terrible, terrible way to die. So being able to choose to go with dignity is less terrifying.” (Maynard 2014) “Brittany 's death was not a victory for a political cause. It was a tragedy, hastened by despair and aided by the culture of death invading our country.” (Morana 2014)
Brittany Maynard, a woman known for her advocacy in the controversial topic of assisted suicide, officially ended her life this fall after learning of her fatal brain tumor. After complaining of horrible headaches, she decided to see a doctor where they gave her this traumatic news. She had two corrective surgeries to try and stop the growth of her large tumor, but they were unsuccessful. Her doctor then suggested full brain radiation, but after months of researching this option, along with many other, she knew her quality of what short life she had left would quickly deteriorate. With the help of her family, friends, and newly-wed husband, she made the decision to move with her loved ones from her California home to Oregon, where death with
The issue of PAD is one of liberty to do what one wants. Dying on one’s terms seems at first to be an issue of noninterference (negative liberty) (Stone, 2012, p124). Put another way, someone might say “Don’t interfere with the way I choose to die.” However, PAD doesn’t happen in a void. There is an infrastructure to the medical and dying process. It requires support to carry out (positive liberty) (Stone, 2012, p124). Individuals must see a doctor, obtain a diagnosis and obtain life ending medication.
Terminally ill individuals experiencing agonizing illnesses, with a predicted lifespan of six months or less, have little or no control over their lives and deaths. Opposed to the patients who enter a state of vegetation where they have little voluntary say in how, or what they do and most likely established a will, terminally ill patients who can make rather analytic decision are constrained by excruciating pain and disability can’t peacefully end their life in most of America. The only states enacting Death with Dignity are, Washington, Oregon, Vermont ,California and Montana which have legalized doctor assisted euthanasia or death with dignity. According to the 2013 report on Oregon’s Death with Dignity Act, One hundred twenty two medications were written and filled resulting in 90 deaths due to ingestion. From surveys taken of the ill who carried out the act, the most frequent reasons for ending their life were decreasing ability to partake in enjoyable activities (85.8%), loss of autonomy (85.9%), and loss of dignity (72.4%) (Oregon’s Death with Dignity Act-2013). Thus, according to the information it is obvious without a second gland